Hi - I'm Martha! I'm a journalist and product tester at JoyNights. I love to share my ideas and personal sex life experience so that others can learn from my experiences.
read more
Hi - I'm Doris! I've spent decades working in the adult industry, including at several sex toy manufacturers as well as a large brick & mortar sex shop. I love reviewing read more
Last updated: February 24, 2024
JoyNights is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here
Nothing is worse than injuries, irritations, and pain, when you give a go to new techniques in your sex life with your partner. As the trust and the desire to do it again may get lost forever. That’s why it’s so important to prepare in advance and choose the right tools for experiments such as fisting. Use lube during fisting to ensure the process is as smooth as possible.
For your convenience, we’ve tested 10 products and compiled a list of the 5 best lubes for fisting, with the Master Series Desensitizing Invade being our top pick. We’ve included water-based products as they are versatile options that you can easily use with a condom and toys. They also come in different packages like a pump, squeeze, and pot, choose the one you find more effective in use.
More features: vegetarian-friendly, numbing effect
If you have some experience in fisting and need a product designed for an amazing sexual experience, consider picking the Master Series Desensitizing Invade. It is designed for numbing the ass or vagina for a painless and smooth play. This is as intense as things get as it makes it possible to have the deepest penetration.
Formulated with 5% benzocaine, petroleum, and mineral oil, this product will deliver a fantastic experience and ensure your partner feels relaxed. As such, if you plan on using larger toys, this will be an excellent option. The numbing agents included in the formula are quite intense, so you will not feel any sensation on your ass.
After applying the cream, the giver might also feel this product’s effect, so consider using a condom to avoid numbing your penis. Please note that oil-based lubes can reduce the effectiveness of latex condoms.
Why did it make our list? The Master Series Desensitizing Invade is vegetarian-friendly lube for fisting ideal for extreme sexual experience. It is long-lasting, contains a numbing effect, and makes the entire fisting moment easier and enjoyable.
What is not ideal about it? The screw-top jar could have been easier to open.
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 2997 people in the past 30 days
9.5
Customer Feedback
Based on cross-platform reviews
9.1
Brand Reputation
Based on web analytics & content of negative reviews
More features: preservative-free, odorless, for sensitive skin
pjur Woman Nude is among the best lubes for vaginal fisting. One of the best things about this product is the gel-like texture that offers a long-lasting pleasure. The water-based lubricant is ideal for ladies since it’s super gentle on their delicate skin.
Some of the ingredients included in this product include sodium saccharin, Ethoxydiglycol, water, and citric acid. The natural lube for fisting doesn’t contain any taste or odor, so it won’t mess up your PH balance.
Since this lube is water-based, you can use both Nitrite gloves and latex gloves. As such, you won’t need to be extra cautious when selecting the right fisting toys and fisting gloves. In terms of packaging, pjur Woman Nude comes in a cute and secure bottle that can easily fit in your bag when traveling.
What stands out? Like all the products on this list, the pjur Woman Nude offers a relaxing and painless effect making your fisting experience more fun and a lot easier. It is also ideal for women with sensitive skin.
What cons did we manage to find? It could have better if the lube weren’t as sticky.
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 7435 people in the past 30 days
9.4
Customer Feedback
Based on cross-platform reviews
9.0
Brand Reputation
Based on web analytics & content of negative reviews
Another great option is the ID Pleasure Tingling Sensation Lubricant, which enhances stimulation ensuring you and your partner experience pleasure. The best part is that lube is formulated for both men and women.
It is formulated from natural botanical extracts that provide a tingling sensation for more arousal and pleasure. Then, the red clover increases blood circulation, ensuring you stay as relaxed and aroused as possible.
Fisting requires the receiver to be as calm as possible, and this product will help your partner achieve that. As you can see, this is more than just a regular lubricant. Other ingredients included in this formula include Benzoate potassium, Biloba extract, water, and Methylparaben.
Also worth noting is that ID pleasure is compatible with different types of toys and rubbers such as polyisoprene, polyurethane, silicone, and latex. As such, you get your favorite toy or condom without worrying about its effectiveness.
After having your frisky moment with your partner, rinsing this lube off your hand should be pretty easy.
What do we love it for? All in all, the ID Pleasure Tingling Sensation is an award-winning lubricant for fisting that makes the activity pleasurable, enjoyable and liberating. Whether you are experienced or a beginner, this will be a great option.
What were we disappointed with? It would have been better if the lube delivered a more intense heat.
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 3167 people in the past 30 days
9.3
Customer Feedback
Based on cross-platform reviews
9.2
Brand Reputation
Based on web analytics & content of negative reviews
Unlike our previous products that contain one property, the Doc Johnson TitanMen Triple Duty con is a combination of silicone and water-based lube. This combination gives it a creamy texture making it one of the best lubes for anal fisting. Silicone makes it long-lasting lube, meaning you won’t need to get another filling after a few minutes. Instead, you and your partner can focus and enjoy the moment.
If you are into solo play, this lube will also be a great option. The versatility of the product makes it ideal for satisfying all your sexual needs. We also like the design of the 8 oz bottle. It features a pump that makes it easy to access the lube.
So, what’s in the bottle. Some of the key ingredients included are shea butter extract, water, coconut oil, urea, and colloidal silver. The USA made lube doesn’t contain colors or parabens making it a safe option.
Why did it make our list? The Doc Johnson TitanMen Triple Duty is ideal for both anal and vaginal use. It is versatile, has an amazing design, and long-lasting to ensure it finishes as you finish.
What is not ideal about it? The manufacturer could have provided a 32 oz bottle.
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 3364 people in the past 30 days
9.2
Customer Feedback
Based on cross-platform reviews
8.9
Brand Reputation
Based on web analytics & content of negative reviews
If you are looking for a long-lasting lube for fisting, you will not go wrong with the Lovehoney Enjoy. One of the best things about this formula is the extra thickness that ensures you have a painless and long-lasting experience. Unlike regular lubes, the thick textures prevent it from dripping.
Moreover, the slippery texture makes penetration smoother, especially when using sex toys. So, get the Love honey, enjoy, relax, and get ready for a fun time. It is made from a vegan-ingredients, so you don’t need to worry about your safety while using this product.
Some of the ingredients included in this formula are water, sodium hydroxide, propylene, and benzoic acid. Since this a water-based, you can use it latex condom or sex toy. Another great thing about such a lube is that it doesn’t leave stains on your hands and beddings. Once you are done, you simply need to rinse your hands with water.
What stands out? All things considered, the Lovehoney Enjoy is an excellent option since it is long-lasting, easy to use, and vegan friendly.
What cons did we manage to find? The bottle could have been larger.
Fisting is among the most erotic and intimate sexual activities you might experience. It can be an enjoyable and pleasurable experience, especially when you have the right lube for fisting.
In this comprehensive guide, we have looked at some of the best brands in the market today, but to make your work even much easier, we give you more information to help you get the best lube for fisting.
Can you enjoy fisting?
Fisting might seem like an intense sexual activity, but most people enjoy it for different reasons. For some, it might be the sensation of pleasure and satisfaction they get from fisting, while others enjoy the intimacy the process involves. Fisting stimulates the prostate gland, which can bring pleasure and make some people experience an intense orgasm.
And for some, it is the joy of knowing that they trust each other enough to engage in such an intimate activity. As long as you and your partner are comfortable and happy during fisting, there is nothing wrong with it.
Safety Tips and tricks- how to avoid trauma during
Unlike most sexual activities, fisting has a low-risk of spreading STIs and HIV. However, you still need to take some precautions to avoid trauma and physical damage. Let’s look at some of the things you can do to make fisting safer.
Get Gloves
The first thing you need to do is wear gloves to prevent any abrasions or germs from getting in your vagina or rectum. Gloves also prevent tears and from long fingernails. Ensure the gloves fits nicely because any hanging fold can cause discomfort. If you are using an oil-based lube, consider using nitrile gloves because an oil-based one can degrade latex gloves. They are also ideal for people with latex allergies.
Start slow
For you and your partner to enjoy fisting, you will need time to relax your body and mind. So, it’s something you rush into. The activity is more of a team effort, and the giver needs to understand the receiver and make them as comfortable as possible. Before you start, communicate with your partner and ensure you are on the same page.
Lube is a must
Unlike other sexual activities that don’t necessarily require you to lube, you must use lube during fisting. In fact, it requires more than other activities. Some prefer using oil, creamy lubes, while others go for slicker-based lubes. You can also use coconut oil.
Train your butt
Yes, you read that right. Your butt has two extremely sensitive muscles that must relax for anything to go in there. There are multiple ways to train your butt, but we recommend using a plug-shaped toy or small-sized vibrator to stretch the hole. You want to start slow and work your way up. You can also invest in a dilating toy that is specifically designed for stretching the ass.
Extra stimulation
Fisting requires you and your partner to be as relaxed as possible. One thing that can help you stay calm and focused is to stimulate sensitive areas such as the clitoris or vagina. This helps to increase the pleasure and make your fisting experience a success.
Know your limits
It’s human nature to push as hard as they can. However, you need to be moderate, especially if it’s your first time. The last thing you want is to damage your sex toy before enjoying it. Moreover, listen to your body to avoid pain and trauma.
Be attentive to your partner because fisting should bring pleasure for both of you. And if at any point the activity becomes extremely painful, then you need to stop. You can visit your doctor and find out the cause of the pain.
How to use fisting lube
Don’t be stingy
One of the most important things to keep in mind fisting is always being generous with the lube. Having great lubrication is the key to making your fisting session fun and smooth. There is nothing wrong with using too much lube.
Apply lube on the giving and receiving part
Next is to apply the slippery staff on both the receiver and giver. This helps to prevent friction between both areas that are in contact. Apply the lube on the item getting inside and ensure you remove any gripper area.
Be ready with a towel.
We mentioned earlier that fisting could be quite messy, so you need to have a towel ready to get rid of any dripping quickly. To avoid having stains on your bedding, you can always put a few towels to hold any body fluids or lube.
Relax and enjoy
We get it; feeling a large thing penetrating in your ass or vagina can be a bit strange, especially if this is your first time. Especially with anal fisting, you will need to completely relax your sphincter muscles for you to go get pleasure.
We recommend using dim lights, romantic music, or a hot bath to help you calm down. Consider using something that appeals to you to help you remain as chill as possible. During fisting, don’t be shy to experiment with different positions to learn what gives you maximum pleasure.
How to pick the best lube for fisting
From silicone-based to water-based based lubes, there is a wide range of options to choose from. And this can be quite challenging, especially if this is your first time trying out fisting. That’s why we have looked at the thing you need to consider and answered some of the most common questions about this topic.
Formula
Lubes come in different formulas, including silicone-based, oil-based, and water-based. So, you just need to select one that works for you and your partner. All these main formulas have their advantages and disadvantages.
In general, if you want to try out fisting with your long-term partner, silicone and oil-based will be the best formula. Then, for casual sex, a water-based will be the best idea since you can easily use it with a condom and toys. You can use a combination of both formulas, such as the Doc Johnson TitanMen Triple Duty.
Versatility
Some lubricants are specifically formulated for fisting, but others are versatile, meaning you can use them for several purposes. A product made for fisting might be quite effective in that particular activity but may not be as great in other tasks. A lube like the ID Pleasure Tingling Sensation Lubricant is ideal for both men and women and can be used for a wide range of activities.
Price
Most lubes for fisting range between $12 to $ 40. Products that come with extra effects tend to be a bit pricier than other creams. Silicone-based lubes are also more expensive than other formulas because of the nature of their making.
Bottle design
While fisting can be a fun and pleasurable activity, it can also be quite messy, especially when using lube. As such, you want to use a lube easy to access and use. The best fisting lubes come in a well-packaged container that makes it easy to access the formula.
If you want to travel with your product, we recommend getting one with a squeezy top bottle like the pjur Woman Nude. On the other hand, if you want one that will offer a quick and easy top-up, then you might want to go for a pump-put lube.
Thickness
If you want to experience a painless experience, then runny and thin lubes will not get the job done. We recommend using a thick lube such as the Lovehoney Enjoy for high-level and lasting lubrication.
Effect
Most of the best lube for vaginal and anal fisting provide extra useful features such as calming and numbing effects. A good example is the Master Series Desensitizing Invade, which contains a numbing effect making your fisting session more pleasurable and easier for you and your partner, but remember – numbing effects are better taken by users who know what they are doing, and definitely not fit for first-time experience.
Extra features
Other important factors you need to look out for include allergies. If you are prone to allergies, consider choosing a hypoallergenic lubricant and one that doesn’t contain parabens. All the products discussed in this article are skin-friendly and do not contain harmful elements.
That said, if you have a silicone allergy, it’s best to select oil or water-based lube to avoid any problem.
Although you can still use oil-based lubes, they may not be as good and thick as water or silicone-based lubes. They can reduce the effectiveness of a condom since most of them are made from latex.
However, if you plan to use a non-latex condom, then you can safely use oil-based lubes. Another thing is that these types of lube are not easy to clean and can make the fisting a bit messy.
The first thing you need to do before starting your fisting session is to make an anal douching. We are not talking about a quick wipe but a deep cleaning process simple that can take up to 40 minutes, especially for anal fisting.
You need to be careful and effective during cleaning because a dirty ass might be a turn-off and ruin the entire session. The deep cleaning also helps to relax the muscles making penetration more comfortable. To be extra cautious you can purchase special gloves.
Fisting can be quite intense, so it’s not unusual to have lube and body fluids left behind your clothes. Generally, water-based lubes are less likely to cause stains, but you can easily get rid of them using warm water and detergent if it happens.
Silicone-based lubes can also cause stains that might require you to put your clothes in the washer. Getting silicone out of your bedding is easy. When it comes to oil-based lubes, they can be quite difficult to clean, and some can even leave permanent stains.
Our Verdict
Our first pick is the Master Series Desensitizing Invade, which is a terrific product. It provides a numbing effect that makes it possible to have a smooth and painless penetration. This is a solid option for both vaginal and anal sex. If you want a skin-to-skin contact, this is for you.
Our second pick is the pjur Woman Nude, which is designed to make women feel as comfortable as possible when fisting. It is a safe option for those who want a pleasurable and pain-free session. The lack of preservative also makes it ideal for women because it will not disturb the sensitive areas.
Our third pick is the Doc Johnson TitanMen Triple Duty, which is one of the best lubricants for both men and women. The combination of water and silicone-based is the most striking thing about this formula. The thickness and durability of the Doc Johnson TitanMen allow you to take the fisting session to a whole new level.
Unlike most sexual activities, fisting has a low-risk of spreading STIs and HIV. However, you still need to take some precautions to avoid trauma and physical damage. Let’s look at some of the things you can do to make fisting safer.
From silicone-based to water-based based lubes, there is a wide range of options to choose from. And this can be quite challenging, especially if this is your first time trying out fisting. That’s why we have looked at the thing you need to consider and answered some of the most common questions about this topic.
While fisting can be a fun and pleasurable activity, it can also be quite messy, especially when using lube. As such, you want to use a lube easy to access and use. The best fisting lubes come in a well-packaged container that makes it easy to access the formula.
