9 Best Butt Plugs for All Tastes – Stylish, Vibrating and Kinky (Winter 2022)

This article will help you choose the best anal plug from the plethora of models - we'll explore various materials, functions, and specific designs
By
reviewed
Reviewed by
Last updatedLast updated: October 13, 2022
Joy Nights is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here

You can agree with us that going ahead with anal sex without the right level of preparation is not a wise move. And a very important part of the preparation is relaxing and warming up the anus with a nice butt plug.

Besides, there are different butt plugs on the market with various specialties that picking the best butt toys out of the pool can cause unnecessary headaches. To make life easier for you, we’ve tested many top-rated products and judged them based on the anal plug material, size, design, safety, durability, and extra features that determine excellent quality. In this article, we’ll recommend the 9 unique butt plugs that most impressed us during the testing process. Read on to learn more about the best butt plugs, how they work, and find how much is a butt plug.

?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 4335 people in the past 30 days
9.7
Customer Feedback
Customer Feedback
9.2
Brand Reputation
Based onweb analytics
9.2
Features & Benefits
Product Review
9.5
9.7
1
Editor’s Choice

OhMiBod LUMEN

Features
  • Material: body-safe silicone
  • Top circumference: 1.2 in
  • Insertable length: 3.9 in
  • Working time: 1 hr
  • Warranty: 1-year limited

More features: phthalate free, waterproof, 2.5 hrs charging time, remote app compatible

Not many butt plugs feel more comfortable than the OhMiBod Lumen. Not only is this anal plug made from body-friendly silicone, but the material also features Velvet Wave™ comfort technology which promises incredible pleasure and comfort. Additionally, this highest rated butt plug boasts four manual mode pulsations and it can be remotely controlled.

If you’re an adventurous couple, the OhMiBod Lumen is arguably the ideal choice for you. Thanks to the OhMiBod Remote™ App and the Kiiroo’s FeelConnect App, you and your partner can be in on the action. While you wear the plug, your partner can control the vibrations and let you writhe in pleasure. Not many people will disagree if you call this product the best all-day butt plug.

What makes it stand out?

  • There are many things to like about the OhMiBod Lumen butt plug, aren’t they? From the plug’s body-friendly silicone with a comfort technology to its phthalate-free construction, we liked the experience we got from this device. We can’t but mention the remote control apps that make long-distance play a breeze. Additionally, this plug boasts a signature Club Vibe® mode that enables the device to sync its vibrations to any ambient sound.

Which disadvantages must you keep in mind?

  • With an insertable length of fewer than four inches, some users may find the OhMiBod Lumen anal plug to be too small. Of course, such users can only be experienced ones. In our opinion, since this plug is not for beginners, the insertable length could be more than four inches. Another part of this anal plug we felt needs improvement is the charging time. The charging time could be shorter than 2.5 hours.
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 7200 people in the past 30 days
9.6
Customer Feedback
Customer Feedback
9.2
Brand Reputation
Based onweb analytics
9.3
Features & Benefits
Product Review
9.4
9.6
2
Best Anal Plug for Men

Lelo Hugo

Features
  • Material: body-safe silicone
  • Top circumference: 1.6 in
  • Insertable length: 5.5 in
  • Working time: 2 hrs

More features: remote control, 8 vibration settings, waterproof

The LELO HUGO™ anal plug is a prostate massager with a sleek design that is complemented by two ultra-powerful motors. Besides that, this anal plug features a SenseMotion™ response remote control with a wireless range of up to 12 meters. This remote control also makes browsing through the 8 adjustable settings a breeze.

If you have prostate and you’re looking for an amazing butt plug to stimulate it, the LELO HUGO™ may just be what you’ve been looking for. While the device massages your prostate, the base’s secondary motor stimulates your perineum for overwhelming pleasure, making it arguably the best prostate butt plug.

What makes it stand out?

  • The LELO HUGO™ butt plug is an excellent prostate massager, isn’t it? We liked that the plug comes with a remote control that boasts a relatively high wireless range and can browse through the device's 8 adjustable vibration settings. Also, we liked the product’s super-smooth silicone that glides naturally, tempting us to call it the best silicone butt plug. Additionally, the anal plug is 100% waterproof, making it a perfect butt plug shower use.

Which disadvantages must you keep in mind?

  • To be clear: inserting the LELO HUGO™ prostate massager into your anus is one of the easiest things to do as long as you use a lot of water-based lubricant. However, we noticed a major flaw in the plug’s design: the device hardly stays in place if the user moves. This makes it a bit difficult to massage the prostate as you desire. In our opinion, the prostate massager could be better designed to stay in place.
RELATED: 5 Best Lelo Vibrators for Any Person to Get the Ultimate Pleasure (Winter 2022)
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 2650 people in the past 30 days
9.4
Customer Feedback
Customer Feedback
8.9
Brand Reputation
Based onweb analytics
9.0
Features & Benefits
Product Review
9.3
9.4
3
Best Jewel Butt Plug

Rosebuds LoveRing

Features
  • Material: stainless steel
  • Top circumference: 1 in
  • Insertable length: 2 in
  • Weight: 6.5 oz

More features: Swarovski crystal, ring cutting, tapered tip

The Rosebuds LoveRing butt plug is made from stainless steel—a departure from silicone anal plugs. It features an exciting Swarovski crystal at the base, making for a glamorous view. The product also boasts a ring function that lets you pull and tug the plug during play. Plus, the smooth and tapered tip eases insertion, making this model the best butt plug for sex.

If you’re looking for the perfect steel butt plug that allows your partner in the game, the Rosebuds LoveRing is your guy. While the sparkling Swarovski crystal at the plug’s base provides your partner an exciting visual, the ring function allows your partner to pull and tug the plug for extra sensation.

What makes it stand out?

  • The Rosebuds LoveRing does not lack in both design and functionality. The base of this butt plug features a Swarovski crystal that entices your partner as they look between your cheeks. Some may even call this mini butt plug the best jewel butt plug thanks to the amazing visual it provides. That’s not all we liked: the ring opening between the bulb and base allows your partner to be in the game as they pull and tug the plug.

Which disadvantages must you keep in mind?

  • If you’re new to butt play, the Rosebuds LoveRing is far from being an ideal butt plug for you. Essentially, it’s ideal for only experienced anal players. In our opinion, the plug could be better designed to suit less experienced players. Also, this product is expensive and that can be a deal-breaker for some people. Surely, the plug’s price can be cheaper than it is.
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 6117 people in the past 30 days
9.4
Customer Feedback
Customer Feedback
9.1
Brand Reputation
Based onweb analytics
8.9
Features & Benefits
Product Review
9.0
9.4
Features
  • Material: silicone
  • Top circumference: 1.28-1.59 in
  • Insertable length: 3.98-5.03 in
  • Working time: 1 hr

More features: 9 vibration patterns, 1.5 hrs charging time, USB charger, waterproof

The Adam & Eve Rechargeable Vibrating Anal Training Kit—as the name suggests—consists of multiple butt plugs. The kit features a small plug, a medium, plug, and a large plug—all of different lengths and circumferences. Each anal plug is made from silicone and boasts 9 intense vibration speeds.

If you’re looking for the best butt plug set to fulfill your anal fantasies, the Adam and Eve Rechargeable Vibrating Anal Training Kit provides you the perfect choice. While you can start with the small plug, you can move on to the medium butt plug and the large plug in the future. Essentially, this kit is all about fulfilling your anal play journey, being the best of the available butt plug kits.

What do we love it for?

  • First of all, we liked that the Adam and Eve Rechargeable Vibrating Anal Training Kit comes with three butt plugs of varying sizes. These sizes range from small to large. No doubt, the product features the best ass plug for beginners as the small size could easily qualify for the best first butt plug. Each plug is flexible and super-smooth with a base for safety and comfort. Also, these plugs offer 9 intense speeds that promise incredible sensations.

What were we disappointed with?

  • In terms of design and functionality, there’s almost nothing not to like about the Adam and Eve Rechargeable Vibrating Anal Training Kit. However, the packaging is not as faultless because the kit may arrive incomplete, affecting user satisfaction. Without any doubt, this can be a deal-breaker for most buyers. If the kit is fully sealed with the complete items, then this product will be near perfection.
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 3650 people in the past 30 days
9.3
Customer Feedback
Customer Feedback
9.0
Brand Reputation
Based onweb analytics
9.1
Features & Benefits
Product Review
9.2
9.3
5
Best Warming Butt Plug

Lora DiCarlo TILT

Features
  • Material: silicone
  • Top circumference: 1.24 in
  • Insertable length: 2.9 in
  • Warranty: 1-year limited

More features: heated up to 104°F, 10 vibration patterns and speeds

The Lora Dicarlo TILT butt plug is right there among the best vibrating butt plugs, featuring two independent motors that deliver intense vibrations. The plug also features three vibration patterns and seven intensity settings. Additionally, the device boasts a unique warming technology—WarmSense™—that delivers a natural, sensual heat (up to 104°F—just above body temperature).

If you’re looking for a butt plug that can do it all, then you need not look further because the Lora Dicarlo TILT has got you. The toy’s versatile design stimulates the prostate & perineum or the G-spot & clitoris simultaneously. So, if you put this product in the bracket of best female butt plugs or best anal butt plugs for men, you won’t be out of line.

Why is it special?

  • No doubt, vibrations bring another level of excitement to anal play and the Lora Dicarlo TILT butt plug offers that in abundance. Thanks to the two motors with seven intensity settings, you’ll get nothing but intense rumbly vibrations. And there’s no way we won’t mention the plug's warming technology that delivers quick, even heat throughout the device to relax your muscle. Additionally, we liked the ingenious design that makes the plug ideal for anal and vaginal stimulation.

What are the flaws?

  • When you’ve got an exciting versatile sex toy like the Lora Dicarlo TILT, you want it to be beginner-friendly but that’s not exactly the case here. Even though the device has a modest top circumference of 1.24 inches, anal newbies may still struggle to get comfortable with the vibrations. In our opinion, this multipurpose plug could be more beginner-friendly.
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 4780 people in the past 30 days
9.1
Customer Feedback
Customer Feedback
8.7
Brand Reputation
Based onweb analytics
8.8
Features & Benefits
Product Review
8.9
9.1
6
Best Metal Butt Plug

njoy Pure Plug

Features
  • Material: stainless steel
  • Top circumference: 1-1.5 in
  • Insertable length: 3-4 in

More features: waterproof, allergen-free

The njoy Pure Plug is made from medical-grade, corrosion-resistant stainless steel and it boasts a lustrous finish that provides an amazing feeling against your bare skin. Additionally, the plug is available in three designs, including small, medium, and large. Plus, it sports a waterproof design.

Whether you want a bedroom play or outdoor play, the njoy Pure Plug is ideal for you. You can wear it to the club or the movies for some naughty hidden stimulation. And you don’t have to worry about the plug staying in place because its large head provides good retention and comfort for long-term wear.

What makes it stand out?

  • The njoy Pure Plug has many exciting features that are aided by its excellent stainless steel construction. With three different size options, this plug presents itself as an ideal option for beginners. Also, the sex toy promises long-term comfort and good retention if you want to wear it for a long time. Furthermore, this retention butt plug is waterproof. No doubt, it’s up there with the best metal butt plugs.

Which disadvantages must you keep in mind?

  • Even though the njoy Pure Plug is waterproof, it is not water-resistant. That means you can’t place it in water for more than a few minutes or you risk damaging it. The plug could be better designed to resist water for a longer period. Also, you’ll be disappointed if you’re expecting vibration from this product because it has none. A vibrating function could make it the ultimate outdoor butt plug.
RELATED: 7 Best Metal Butt Plugs – Toys for Temperature Play (Winter 2022)
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 8613 people in the past 30 days
9.0
Customer Feedback
Customer Feedback
8.6
Brand Reputation
Based onweb analytics
8.9
Features & Benefits
Product Review
8.9
9.0
7
Best Inflatable Butt Plug

Colt Extra Large Inflatable Butt Plug

Features
  • Material: silicone
  • Top circumference: 11 in
  • Insertable length: 6 in

More features: 6.5-in total length, allergen-free, suction cup base

The Colt Extra Large Inflatable Butt Plug is exactly what you think it is: a long butt plug that can be inflated. This device features a palm-sized bulb that allows effortless inflation and a strong suction-cup base that allows hands-free use. Also, there’s a detachable hose for inflation and a quick-release button available for instant deflation.

If you’re experienced in anal play and you enjoy great stretch, the Colt Extra Large Inflatable Butt Plug is the ideal option for you. The plug’s girth starts at 5.5 inches and gets bigger to fill up your anus.

What makes it stand out?

  • Everything about the Colt Extra Large Inflatable Butt Plug screams pleasure. From the strong suction-cup base to the quick-release button, you have great features for seamless anal play. We also liked that this plug is made from smooth silicone that is free of latex and phthalates. If you’re wondering which is the best inflatable butt plug or even the best large butt plug, you don’t need to further than this product.

Which disadvantages must you keep in mind?

  • We found the Colt Extra Large Inflatable Butt Plug to be a bit too hard. In our opinion, it could be softer to enhance pleasure. Also, the hose pops out of the plug too often. Of course, this can frustrate anal play. Most times, you’ll need help to inflate the plug successfully. Surely, the hose could be better designed to save users from this headache.
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 2409 people in the past 30 days
8.8
Customer Feedback
Customer Feedback
8.7
Brand Reputation
Based onweb analytics
8.3
Features & Benefits
Product Review
8.6
8.8
Features
  • Material: stainless steel
  • Top circumference: 3.75 in
  • Insertable length: 2.75 in
  • Total length: 14.5 in

More features: allergen-free, splashproof

The Dominix Deluxe Fox Tail Butt Plug is made from metal. It features a flared base that protects you from an embarrassing visit to the hospital. Also, the plug can be warmed or cooled in water for temperature play.

If you and your partner are a kinky couple and you’d like to explore pet/animal play, the Dominix Deluxe Butt Plug is an ideal tool for your gear. The faux fur tail makes foxy roleplay fun and creates the persona of Mr. and Mrs. Fox!

Why are we impressed?

  • First of all, we liked that the Dominix Deluxe Butt Plug is made from skin-friendly metal and is free of known allergens such as latex and phthalates. And there’s also a flared base that stops the plug from getting sucked in. This great construction makes this wearable butt plug the safest butt plug. Additionally, we liked that this anal plug can be warmed and cooled in water for extra sensational play.

What negatives must you be aware of?

  • The Dominix Deluxe Butt Plug has a great design and is easy to use but the tail is not great. While it’s hard to forgive the fact that it’s not fluffy, it’s even poorly glued to the plug. Plus, the tail is all matted with glue, making it a bit difficult to play with the fur. This quality is surely not good enough and could be improved.
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 9159 people in the past 30 days
8.7
Customer Feedback
Customer Feedback
8.5
Brand Reputation
Based onweb analytics
8.3
Features & Benefits
Product Review
8.3
8.7
Features
  • Material: glass
  • Top circumference: 4 in
  • Insertable length: 3 in
  • Total length: 3.5 in

More features: glows in the dark, velvet storage bag included, hypoallergenic

The Lovehoney Sensual Glass Glow-in-the-Dark Butt Plug is made from ultra-strong glass for precise and firm stimulation. Not only is the plug hypoallergenic, but it’s also ideal for temperature play. And it comes with a storage bag. As it’s just a peace of a wonderful glass without any electronics inside, you can even go swimming with this butt plug!

If you want a glowing star in your butt, try the Lovehoney Sensual Glass Glow-in-the-Dark Butt Plug. And if it’s a glass plug you want, this product has got you. The elegance of this anal plug shines through in the darkness and it feels as good as it looks. Moreover, it is one of the cheap butt plugs on the market.

What makes it stand out?

  • The classy glass construction stands out for us. Not only is the glass classy, but it’s also hypoallergenic, ensuring safe anal play. And it’s safe to use the product with any lubricant. Also, we liked that the plug can be cooled or warmed in water for temperature play. Furthermore, we liked that the anal plug truly shines as advertised that it could easily take the crown as the best glass butt plug.

Which disadvantages must you keep in mind?

  • For the size of the Lovehoney Sensual Glass Glow-in-the-Dark Butt Plug, we were disappointed by the bulky base. In our opinion, the bulky base just doesn’t suit the relatively small size of the plug. This makes the device a bit difficult to use. The base could be made bulky to complement the size of the anal plug.

Things to Consider

Remember we mentioned earlier that picking the best butt plug out of the several options on the market can be tasking. However, if you know where to look, things won’t have to be difficult. Luckily for you, we’ve developed a comprehensive buying guide to make this a seamless process.

How To Wear Butt Plug

Wearing butt plugs is simple – just choose the design you like and put it in

A booty plug needs to be worn properly to be enjoyable Trusted Source Anal Orgasms: 35 Tips, Techniques, Positions, Benefits, and More An anal orgasm is exactly what it sounds like — orgasm that’s achieved through anal stimulation. We’re talking touching, licking, fingering, penetration, and more. If it feels good, anything goes! Curious? Read on to learn more about this backdoor wonder and how to bring your body to orgasm. www.healthline.com . Below, we’ll give you some tips to help you wear your plug properly:

  • Do some foreplay to relax your tense muscles
  • Apply a lot of lube on the plug and around your butt
  • Press the plug’s tip against your butt hole and gently push it in.
  • Increase the pressure gradually as you insert the plug.
  • Stop immediately if you feel pain. Apply more lube and try a different angle or even a smaller plug.

How to Pick the Best Butt Plug Ever

We promised to help you know the right places to look when shopping for the best butt plug vibrator and we’ll deliver on that promise below:

Material

Several materials are used in the construction of good butt plugs. The most popular butt plug materials include silicone, metal, and glass which are known to be body-safe. TPE and rubber are also used for some plugs but we don’t recommend them because they degrade over time.

If you’re trying out an anal plug for the first time, then silicone is the best material for butt plugs, as the OhMiBod Lumen. However, silicone plugs can’t be used with silicone lube. On the other hand, a metal variant such as the Dominix Deluxe Butt Plug or the glass variant such as the Lovehoney Sensual Glass Glow-in-the-Dark Butt Plug can be used with any lube.

Size

Size is a very important factor in the consideration of the ideal butt plug. Whether it’s the top circumference or the insertable length, you want to get the best butt plug size for you. For example, a beginner needs a small size while an experienced anal player will only be satisfied with a large plug.

In terms of butt plug dimensions, products that offer multiple butt plugs with their distinct sizes such as Adam and Eve Rechargeable Vibrating Anal Training Kit and njoy Pure Plug can be smart choices.

Designs

New butt plugs sport varying designs. While some can be jeweled like the Rosebuds LoveRing butt plug, others can have a faux tail like the Dominix Deluxe Fox Tail Butt Plug. Regardless, you can choose any butt plug design that suits your preference.

Vibration

Some butt plug models can be used with apps that allow you to control vibration patterns

Without any doubt, vibration adds to the play. Imagine wearing a butt plug that moves to the movies and having your partner use a remote control to control the vibration up your ass, that would be some fun. Of course, not many products can give you these functions but high-end butt plug such as the LELO HUGO™ can deliver.

Even though the Lora Dicarlo TILT butt plug—another top-quality option—does not have a remote control, it offers intense vibrations. So, if you want to add that extra sensation to your anal play, you know what to do.

Durability and safety

Durability is a very important factor to consider before investing in a butt plug. Even though it’s hard to determine a product’s durability at the point of purchasing it, reading the reviews of users can help make an informed decision and buy the best butt plug for long-term wear.

Another important factor is safety. You want to avoid plugs that can be allergic. Choosing phthalate-free options such as OhMiBod Lumen butt plug and Colt Extra Large Inflatable butt plug can go a long way in ensuring your safety.

According to a recent study by NGO Zero Breast Cancer, phthalate exposure is associated with several reproductive health and developmental problems. So, this is one chemical you want to avoid.

Extra features

The presence of extra features can also influence your choice. For example, the warming technology offered by the Lora Dicarlo TILT butt plug makes it quite attractive. Likewise, the Lovehoney Sensual Glass Glow-in-the-Dark Butt Plug’s storage bag is a great addition.

FAQ

Frankly, a butt plug getting sucked in is an extremely remote possibility because most plugs feature flared bases. However, if you find yourself in an embarrassing position where the plug gets sucked in, you need to relax your muscles and try to remove the device.

If you can’t remove it, you might need to visit the emergency room. As advised by a research magazine, Scientific American Trusted Source Good Vibrations: U.S. Consumer Web Site Aims to Enhance Sex Toy Safety Scientific American is the essential guide to the most awe-inspiring advances in science and technology, explaining how they change our understanding of the world and shape our lives. www.scientificamerican.com , only use toys with a flared base or a string and apply a lot of lube to avoid this unwanted situation.

A butt plug’s edge can squeeze the anus’s delicate lining between the toy and the sphincter, causing decreased blood flow. If prolonged, this can cause ulceration or any other damage. Hence, we advise that you don’t wear your butt plug longer than two to three hours, even when comfortable.

Our Verdict

No doubt, there are many high-quality butt plug models out there but you must be well informed to choose the right option for your anal play. As we’ve mentioned before, certain factors informed our choice of the 9 products on our list. For example, the OhMiBod Lumen which is our editor’s choice boasts multiple vibration levels, a remote control, and more exciting features.

Breathing down this product’s neck is the LELO HUGO™ prostate massager that features two ultra-powerful motors, a remote control, 8 vibrations, waterproof, design, and more. And the Adam and Eve Rechargeable Vibrating Anal Training Kit takes the crown as our best value choice thanks to the multiple interesting butt plugs it offers. Overall, you need to consider the right factors to be able to identify the best butt plug.

References

1.
Anal Orgasms: 35 Tips, Techniques, Positions, Benefits, and More
An anal orgasm is exactly what it sounds like — orgasm that’s achieved through anal stimulation. We’re talking touching, licking, fingering, penetration, and more. If it feels good, anything goes! Curious? Read on to learn more about this backdoor wonder and how to bring your body to orgasm.
2.
Good Vibrations: U.S. Consumer Web Site Aims to Enhance Sex Toy Safety
Scientific American is the essential guide to the most awe-inspiring advances in science and technology, explaining how they change our understanding of the world and shape our lives.
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *