5 Best Tail Butt Plugs Reviewed (Winter 2022)

Joy Nights is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here

Tail butt plugs are an exciting way to spice up your bedroom, but you may be surprised by all the variety you may encounter. If you’re new to this toy, or have experience and want to expand your toy chest, you will want to read our review.

The best tail butt plug is one that makes you feel confident while still being comfortable. It should be easy to insert, and the tail portion should be playful. We’ve found five of the best tail butt plugs on offer, and we’re confident one of them will be perfect for you. There is a white range of colors, from white, to black, and even to pink. They are made from different materials and have different abilities. No matter what you’re in the mood for, you’ll be able to find a tail butt plug that can transform you into the wild animal you always wanted to be.

Quick Summary

Editor’s Choice: DOMINIX Deluxe Medium Animal Tail Butt Plug

"A stainless-steel butt plug with gorgeous black tail. 3 inches of insertable length. 7 ounces of weight. 3.75-inch circumference."
Largest Tail Butt Plug: DOMINIX Deluxe Faux Fox Tail Butt Plug

"A fox tail with larger circumference and length. 4 inches of insertable length. Sensitive skin-friendly. Comes with a carrying case."
Most Exotic Butt Plug: Playful Silicone Small Bunny Tail Butt Plug

"A cute pink bunny tail of comfortable size. Safe silicone. 3.5 inches of circumference. 2.5 inches of insertable length."
Premium Pick: Frisky Faux Fur Fox Tail

"A luxurious white fox tail with a bullet vibe. Vibe is removable. 4.5 inches of circumference. Extra-long tail."
Best Value: Crystal Delights Bunny Tail Butt Plug

"A fluffy bunny tail that is sure to become your partner’s eye candy. Medium-sized circumference. Several colors available. 2.8 inches of insertable length."

Top 5 Tail Butt Plugs Review 2022

9.8

Editor’s Choice

DOMINIX Deluxe Medium Animal Tail Butt Plug

Check priceLovehoney

Features

Insertable length: 3 inches
Circumference: 3.75 inches
Total length: 14.5 inches

More features: weighs 6.7 ounces; flared base

Stylishly black, the DOMINIX Deluxe Medium Animal Tail Butt Plug matches all wardrobe choices and personalities. This tail but plug is perfect for every occasion and is sure to spice things up in the bedroom.

The measurements of the DOMINIX Deluxe Medium Animal Tail Butt Plug are on the small to medium size. It has an insertable length of 3 inches and a circumference of 3.75 inches, which should be comfortable to most people. The addition of the black tail gives it a total length of 14.5 inches.

The butt plug itself is made from stainless steel, which allows it to easily be inserted. The flared bottom construction means it will stay in place which further enhances its comfortability. Just keep in mind that the stainless steel might be quite cool at the beginning, so it is suggested to warm it up before use.

With the DOMINIX Deluxe Medium Animal Tail Butt Plug it’s all about style. You can easily swish the tail around, using it in multiple pleasurable ways.

As an added bonus with the DOMINIX Deluxe Medium Animal Tail Butt Plug, you also get a carrying case. It is a plush velvet, and it allows you to store your tail butt plug as well as other extras, including lube. If you plan on traveling, this is a great accessory.

Overall, for those new to anal play, the DOMINIX Deluxe Medium Animal Tail Butt Plug is a perfect product to start with.

What makes it special?

Comfortable size
Tail is sophisticated and elegant
Includes a velvet carrying case

What cons did we find?

Made from stainless steel so will need to be warmed up first

9.6

Largest Tail Butt Plug

DOMINIX Deluxe Faux Fox Tail Butt Plug

Check priceLovehoney

Features

Insertable length: 4 inches
Circumference: 5 inches
Total length: 16.5 inches

More features: sensitive skin-friendly; safe to use with all lubricants

Butt plugs come in all shapes and sizes. If you’re not used to one, you will want to start out small. If, however, you aren’t new to these toys, then you may be ready for a larger size. The DOMINIX Deluxe Faux Fox Tail Butt Plug, then, is perfect. It has a rather large insertable length of 4 inches and a very wide circumference of 5 inches. Please note these dimensions as they are not made for beginners, and it will either be very uncomfortable or just plain scary.

Experienced tail users, however, will love this stylish butt plug with tail. It is made from stainless steel, and while this gives it a sleek look, you will need to warm it up before insertion.

The tail itself gives the overall length a total of 16.5 inches. The tail is made from gorgeous browns, blacks, and whites, for a very realistic fox tail look. It is long, and there are many fun things you can do with it. The tail is incredibly soft and will really add to you and your partner’s pleasure.

When you purchase the DOMINIX Deluxe Faux Fox Tail Butt Plug, it will arrive in a beautiful case. This is really important as you can store the tail butt plug in its case and not worry about any of the hair becoming damaged. You can use the case for traveling purposes, or just to keep your new toy organized. It’s all part of the complete package, and you’ll be quite impressed with it.

What are our favorite features?

Tail has gorgeous colors
Includes a lovely carrying case
Long and soft tail

What could be better?

Rather large and not for beginners

9.5

Most Exotic Butt Plug

Playful Silicone Small Bunny Tail Butt Plug

Check priceLovehoney

Check PriceSheVibe

Features

Insertable length: 2.5 inches
Circumference: 3.5 inches
Total length: 5 inches

More features: made of safe silicone

Some tail butt plugs are meant to mimic the real-life tails of animals. Others, like the Playful Silicone Small Bunny Tail Butt Plug take on a life all its own. While this is a short, bunny tail, it comes in a vivid pink hue and will really make you stand out. This tail butt plug is perfect for someone who likes to dress up in the bedroom and who isn’t afraid of having a bit of fun.

The Playful Silicone Small Bunny Tail Butt Plug has an insertable length of 2.5 inches and a circumference of 3.5 inches, which makes it perfect for beginners. The bright pink color makes it more whimsical, so you can really play around with it. You don’t have to take yourself too seriously with this product.

The bunny tail itself is quite short and only increases the total length to 5 inches. It’s unassuming and not intimidating, which again makes it perfect for beginners. The butt plug portion is made from silicone and is quite flexible. It is very easy to insert and the material stays warm, another bonus feature for beginners. There is a tapered bulb shape that is quite comfortable to use.

Overall, this is an excellent first butt plug. The biggest issue is with the color. While bright pink is nice for some people, it can be a bit much for others. If there was a range of color options for this item it would make it that much better.

Why did it make our list?

Nice dimensions for beginners
Fun, colorful, and playful
Silicone is a warm material

What is not ideal about it?

Only comes in bright pink

9.2

Premium Pick

Frisky Faux Fur Fox Tail

Check priceLovehoney

Features

Insertable length: 4 inches
Circumference: 4.5 inches
Total length: 20 inches

More features: removable single-speed bullet vibe

The Frisky Faux Fur Fox Tail is meant for those experienced with anal play. It is larger than other products, so be sure to assess your comfort level before purchasing it. The insertable length is 4 inches, and the circumference is 4.5 inches. The addition of a fluffy white tail creates a total length of 20 inches.

We’ve chosen the Frisky Faux Fur Fox Tail as our premium pick for best fox tail butt plug because of the addition of a bullet vibe. This vibe is removable, so you can use the fox tail with or without it. The only complaint is that the vibe is only a single-speed one, which is pretty limiting. Still, the addition of it certainly elevates this product.

The butt plug itself is made from silicone, which is a nice alternative to stainless steel. It is still very easy to insert, especially with the right lube, but silicone is a much warmer material. You won’t have to worry about warming it up, and instead can get right into the fun.

As for the tail, the bright white is quite playful. It is full and busy, and perfectly mimics a fox tail. White might be a bit of a risky color choice, however. As everyone knows, white products, no matter what they are used for, don’t often stay white.

Construction wise, there is a small hoop at the base, which allows for easy removal. However, the tail is not detachable, which makes cleaning a bit more cumbersome.

What do we love it for?

Thick, fluffy tail
Includes a loop for easy removal
Bullet vibe can be removed

What were we disappointed with?

The bullet vibe is only one speed

9.1

Best Value

Crystal Delights Bunny Tail Butt Plug

Check priceLovehoney

Features

Insertable length: 2.8 inches
Circumference: 3.3 inches
Total length: 6 inches

More features: other sizes and colors available

Animal butt plugs can be a bit overwhelming if you’re trying to purchase your first one. There are so many options and you might not be sure what will really work for you. The Crystal Delighrs Bunny Tail Anal Plug is a great option as it is both budget-friendly and small enough for beginners.

The Tailz Bunny Tail Anal Plug has an insertable length of 2.8 inches and a circumference of just 1.05 inches. There aren’t any special effects but will create a unique sensation.

The inclusion of the tail gives it a total length of 6 inches. This is much smaller than similar products, which might be less intimidating to some, and thus more desirable. It can be unnerving to try to figure out what to do with a tail at first, so a smaller, more manageable one can give you a boost of confidence.

Once inserted, the Crystal Delights Bunny Tail Anal Plug looks like a rather cute bunny tail. It is fluffy and has many individual feathers for enhanced sensations. The color is white, however, and as the tail is not detachable, it may cause an extra effort to clean. However, because it is so affordable, if you need to replace it, or decide to upgrade at a later time, you won’t feel like you’re paying out a lot of money.

The plug has a tapered design for increased comfort. It is easy to insert and is semi-flexible, so you can position it just right. It’s easy to get used to this butt plug, and you’ll soon want to play with it all the time.

Why are we impressed?

Very affordable
Easy to insert and use
Smaller size is less intimidating for beginners

What negatives must you be aware of?

White color is hard to clean

Things to Consider

Buying a tail butt plug is a very intimate act. You want to find one that will make you feel both sexy and comfortable. Before you dive in, have a look at our buying guide so you know what to expect.

Features to consider when choosing a tail butt plug

Tail butt plugs come in all shapes and sizes. There are so many to choose from, and it is easy to become overwhelmed. If you’re not sure where to start, think about the features you want and don’t want. Then you’ll have a better idea of how to narrow your search.

Color/ whose tail it imitates

There are many versions of tail butt plugs. For animals, you can expect to find tails that mimic foxes, bunnies, and even cats. Fox and cat tails are longer and thinner. They can be moved around a lot and have different ways you can play with them. Bunny tails are a lot shorter, usually more of a large pom-pom. They are bouncy and fluffy but have less play uses.

As for color, you can find just about anything. White is a common color, as seen in the Crystal Delights Bunny Tail Butt Plug and the Frisky Faux Fur Fox Tail. Just note that while white is aesthetically pleasing, it can be harder to clean and may even stain.

Black is another common color, such as with the DOMINIX Deluxe Medium Animal Tail Butt Plug. Black provides an elegant look and is quite versatile, which is why it is so popular. You can also find more realistic colors, like with the DOMINIX Deluxe Faux Fox Tail Butt Plug. It is a mixture of browns, blacks, and whites, and really imitates a fox.

Finally, you can find synthetic colors in your tail butt plug. The Playful Silicone Small Bunny Tail Butt Plug is an example from our list. It is a very vivid pink. If you’re a playful sort of person, then this color choice will probably appeal to you.

Insertable length and circumference

When it comes to any type of butt plug, there are three main sizes: small, medium, and large. It’s important to start with a small size first to assess your comfort level. If you start out too large, it won’t feel good and can actually be quite intimidating. Once you’ve gotten used to a small size, you can move up to a medium, and then after that, a large size. For reference, small would have an insertable length of about 2.5 inches and a circumference size of 3.5 inches, such as the Playful Silicone Small Bunny Tail Butt Plug. A medium-sized butt plug would have an insertable length of 3 inches and a circumference of 3.75 inches, such as the DOMINIX Deluxe Medium Animal Tail Butt Plug. Finally, a large butt plug would have an insertable length of 4 inches and a circumference size of 5 inches, such as the DOMINIX Deluxe Faux Fox Tail Butt Plug.

Overall length

A tail butt plug is unique in that its overall length takes into consideration the length of the inserted part plus the tail itself. While all butt plugs will be close in size, around a few inches, the tail part will vary greatly.

The smallest product on our list is the Playful Silicone Small Bunny Tail Butt Plug. It has an overall length of just 5 inches. This is a fluffy bunny tail, and so looks more like a giant pom-pom.

If you’re more interested in a fox or cat tail, then you can expect a larger overall length. For example, the Frisky Faux Fur Fox Tail is 20 inches in size.

You might think that length doesn’t really matter, but it’s important to assess your comfort level before purchasing a tail butt plug. If you’re new to it, having a large tail can be really overwhelming as you may not know what to do with it. In this case, a shorter tail might be easier to navigate.

However, if you’re a very adventurous person and want to dive into the world of tail butt plugs, then knowing you’ll have a swishing tail to play with may be exactly what you’re after.

Materials used

The materials used in a tail butt plug are very important to notice. Most butt plugs are made from stainless steel. Not only does this make it easy to insert, but they are very easy to clean afterwards. However, stainless steel can be quite cold, so you will need to take a few moments to warm it up. Otherwise, the experience will not be comfortable. The DOMINIX Deluxe Faux Fox Tail Butt Plug and the DOMINIX Deluxe Medium Animal Tail Butt Plug are examples of stainless steel. Stainless steel is also not flexible, so may be best for those with butt plug experience.

Another common material that is used with butt plugs is silicone. This is preferable to beginners because it is a warm material and therefore doesn’t need a lot of preparation. Silicone is also flexible so again, might be a better option for beginners. The Playful Silicone Small Bunny Tail Butt Plug uses silicone.

Vibrations

Sometimes you want an extra sensation with your tail butt plug. If this is the case, you might want to consider a product that has a vibration option. On our list, the Frisky Faux Fur Fox Tail has a removable vibe inside of it. It only has one speed, but the extra stimulation might be exactly what you’re looking for.

FAQ

How do I make stainless steel plug warmer before use?

Stainless steel is a popular material for butt plugs. It is very hygienic and easy to insert. Unfortunately, it can be quite cold at first. To help warm it up, you can run the plug under warm water. You can also use friction and warm it up in your hands, or even pop it in your mouth first.

How to clean the tail?

When using any type of butt plug, you will want to use a water-based lube. This allows for easy clean up and only requires warm water and mild soap to clean. The tail part of the butt plug can be a bit trickier. If you can, find a model that detaches for easier cleanup. If you need to clean the tail, again use warm water and a mild soap. Let the tail air dry and, if possible, brush it out, so it keeps its shape.

Can faux fur cause any allergic reactions?

Everyone is different and may be allergic to many things. Faux fur is usually made from acrylic. It can have other chemicals in it, so try to look at the label first. If you know you have sensitivities or allergies to specific chemicals, you can always contact the manufacturer directly to check the material list.

Our Verdict

No matter what you are in the mood for, there is a quality butt plug tail for you. Our Editor’s choice is the DOMINIX Deluxe Medium Animal Tail Butt Plug. Made with a sleek, black tail, it is perfect for just about anyone and even adds a bit of sophistication to the bedroom. The DOMINIX Deluxe Faux Fox Tail Butt Plug is made for those with experience using butt plugs. It is a bit larger, but those with experience will find it quite enjoyable. It also has a natural look to it, thanks to the mixture of brown hairs. Finally, if you are just a fun-loving person, the Playful Silicone Small Bunny Tail Butt Plug is a solid option. It is bright pink and looks like a cute bunny tail. No matter what your preferences are, you’ll be able to find the best tail butt plug to liven up the bedroom.