Hi - I'm Martha! I'm a journalist and product tester at JoyNights. I love to share my ideas and personal sex life experience so that others can learn from my experiences.
read more
Hi - I'm Doris! I've spent decades working in the adult industry, including at several sex toy manufacturers as well as a large brick & mortar sex shop. I love reviewing read more
Last updated: May 03, 2025
JoyNights is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here
Butt plugs and constructed in a way that brings you the most pleasure by simulating the right spots. But a metal plug is heaven in so many terms. It won’t lose its shape; it is not porous, so it’s much easier to clean than plastic ones, making it a safer option which is a top priority in any sex toy.
With so many options on the market, it’s getting more challenging and challenging to find a quality metal butt plug, so that’s why our team of experts tested 18 products and compiled a list of the 7 best metal butt plugs, with the Aneros Tempo S2 being our favorite. We’ve included only stainless steel or aluminum butt plugs as these are the safest and rust-resistant materials, while the nickel ones can cause allergic reactions, so try to avoid them. There are butt plugs that are only 2.5 inches long for beginners and 4 inches long for more experienced users.
More features: 4.5 in full length, temperature play
The Aneros Tempo is one of the best small metal butt plugs on the market for a variety of reasons. It is well-made using medical-grade stainless steel, so it is body-safe and durable enough to last for several years, even with regular use. This toy is designed perfectly for amazing prostate stimulation, with gentle curves and a weighted bulbed head to hit the right spot every time you insert it. We also liked that this toy offers versatile use, so it can be used both anally and vaginally. This stainless steel anal plug is also temperature-sensitive, so you can heat it with warm water or cool it in the fridge before use for some interesting new sensations.
Aneros is a popular brand when it comes to anal toys, so it’s no wonder this one is so popular. The Tempo does stand out among this brand’s other toys, though, since it is one of only two models that doesn’t have Aneros’ patented trident shape. Instead, it is long and slim, with a straight body and a bulbed head. The flared base is also a unique feature when compared with the other toys this brand has to offer. The satin-lined box for this toy is also one of our favorite features.
What do we love it for?
The medical-grade stainless steel is durable and safe
Temperature sensitive for warm or cool play
Small size is perfect for those inexperienced with anal play
Versatile enough for vaginal and anal use
What were we disappointed with?
The metal contains nickel, which could cause allergic reactions
More features: 6 vibration modes, 60 minutes working time, waterproof
If you like vibrating toys, you may want to try out the Nexus Cestos. This metal anal plug includes a built-in vibrator, which offers 6 different modes that offer varying experiences for you to enjoy. These include low, medium, and high speeds, as well as a few different pulse options that stimulate your back end in the most pleasant ways possible. The vibrations are easy to alter using the handy remote control included with this firm, aluminum toy. It is rechargeable as well, using the magnetic USB charge cord. It’s also easy to tell when it is ready to go since there is a red light on the toy when it is charging and a green one when it’s ready to go.
As well as being a sturdy, rechargeable, remote control toy, the Nexus Cestos is also one of the most durable and comfortable toys that we’ve found. It has a smooth, tapered head that is easy to insert, though the 5-inch circumference at the widest point may be too wide for beginners. There are also ridges for some extra stimulation and a flared base to keep the toy firmly in place after insertion.
What makes it stand out?
Cordless remote is easy to use and allows for couple’s play
6 vibration modes offer varying stimulation
It is rechargeable for consistent use
It is fully waterproof for shower or bath time use.
Which disadvantages must you keep in mind?
This toy may be too expensive for those on a budget
May be too wide for beginners to anal sex
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 4963 people in the past 30 days
9.5
Customer Feedback
Based on cross-platform reviews
9.0
Brand Reputation
Based on web analytics & content of negative reviews
Those looking for some quality metal butt plus without spending a fortune will love the Lovehoney Jewelled Metal Butt Plug Set. This set includes 3 anal plugs of varying sizes, including 2.5, 3, and 3.5 inches of insertable pleasure. All three of these toys have a lovely design, with a smooth, tapered head, a slim neck, and a flared base. We also liked the pretty, clear jewel on each of the bases, which sparkles mischievously once the toy is inserted in the nether regions. This trio of toys is stainless steel, so they are durable and waterproof and can be used anywhere you like.
As well as being a great choice for those who can’t afford expensive toys, the Lovehoney Jewelled Metal Butt Plug Set is also perfect for beginners. The small toy is the perfect starter butt plug, thanks to the slimmer 3.5-inch circumference that is comfortable for first-timers. The two other pieces get progressively larger, so you can work your way through them as you see fit. We did find the base to be a bit small, which made it hard to grip. There also wasn’t any type of storage bag included to keep them organized.
Why are we impressed?
It has a great low price that can fit into any budget
The jeweled base is pretty to look at after insertion
3 plugs included of varying sizes
They are made of durable stainless steel
What negatives must you be aware of?
The base on these toys is small, so could be hard to grip for removal
No storage bag is included
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 4780 people in the past 30 days
9.4
Customer Feedback
Based on cross-platform reviews
9.0
Brand Reputation
Based on web analytics & content of negative reviews
Not everyone is ready to try out a large butt plug, due to inexperience with anal play or not enjoying large items inserted into their back end. That’s where small toys like the njoy Pure Plug come in handy. This small butt plug has only 3 inches of insertable length and is 3.1 inches in circumference, so we found it to be compact and comfortable for even first-timers. This stainless steel butt plug has a smooth finish, with a curved body and bulbed head that fits the shape of your insides perfectly. The base is wide, with a handy ring that makes it easy to grip for insertion, adjustments, or removal.
Njoy is known for its quality metal toys, with unique designs that make them stand out from other brands. All of their toys are made using 316-grade stainless steel, which is high-quality, durable, and long-lasting, with a lustrous finish that looks fantastic. The Pure Plug is one of their smallest toys, giving you a great starter model to test out before moving onto the larger sizes. Included with the Pure Plug is a presentation box with a lovely satin tray insert.
Why is it special?
The ringed base makes it easy to grip during play or removal
The small size is perfect for beginners
It includes a satin-lined storage case
The curved design is comfortable, even for long sessions
What are the flaws?
The price of this toy isn’t exactly budget-friendly
This plug is small and slim, so may not be large enough for experienced users
The anal cavity is full of more nerve endings than most people realize, so a ribbed toy can be much more pleasurable than a smooth one. The Doxy Ribbed Butt Plug proves this after it’s inserted, with the ribbed texturing at the base of the bulbed head rubbing those sensitive areas perfectly for an even more enjoyable experience than you may be expecting. This toy is also well-made, using durable aluminum that can be cooled or heated for some interesting temperature play. It has 4 inches of insertable length and a 4.5-inch circumference, so it is a great choice for beginners and intermediate users, though it may be a bit small for those more experienced with anal play. We also like the slim shaft and wide base, which work together to keep this toy in place.
There are two options for this Doxy toy, including the ribbed version we’re discussing here and a smooth version. The smooth one doesn’t have that texturing on the bulb, so it can’t offer the same stimulation that this one is capable of. To keep your chosen butt plug safe, there is also a handy aluminum case with a soft inner lining included.
What are its best features?
The price is decent for those on a budget
It can be cooled or heated for some stimulating temperature play
The toy is completely waterproof
A sturdy aluminum case is included for storage
What could be improved?
The ribbing does make it a bit more difficult to remove
The size is a bit small for experienced users
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 6742 people in the past 30 days
9.1
Customer Feedback
Based on cross-platform reviews
9.0
Brand Reputation
Based on web analytics & content of negative reviews
Though it isn’t the most important part of a good butt plug, having one that is as attractive to look at as it is to use makes it that much more fun to use. The Rainbow Gem Rose Gold Metal Butt Plug is a stylish piece, with a soft rose gold color and a heart-shaped base that includes a pretty rainbow-colored faux gem attached. Of course, this pretty piece may not be a popular choice among men to use for themselves, though we’re sure they’ll love to see that pretty piece sparkling in their lady’s derriere.
This anal toy is a great option for ladies, though some men may enjoy wearing something flashy and pink as well from time to time. It is somewhat small, which makes it a good choice for those with beginner or intermediate experience with anal play. We liked that it is made of durable nickel-free aluminum alloy, with a smooth finish that makes it easy to insert. This toy is also waterproof, body-safe, and can be used with any type of lubricant without worrying about damage. The metal is also easy to clean, so this toy is always ready to use when you need it.
Why is it special?
The pretty rainbow gem on the base is eye-catching
The small size is perfect for beginners
This toy has a great low price
The metal is body-safe and easy to clean
What are the flaws?
A bit too small for those more experienced with anal play
The pink color and heart shape may not be appealing for male users
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 2813 people in the past 30 days
8.9
Customer Feedback
Based on cross-platform reviews
8.6
Brand Reputation
Based on web analytics & content of negative reviews
More features: 18.5 in full length, splashproof, 3.3 oz weight
The Long Fox Tail Butt Plug is a combination of anal toy and furry costume all in one attractive piece. The plug is made of durable stainless steel, so it can be used with any type of lubricant. It is also waterproof and great for some temperature play if you want to spice things up even more. The tail is soft and pretty, with grayish fur poking out of your nether regions to give you a sexy animal appearance. The only issue that we noticed was that the tail can be coated with lube and other fluids, especially near the base, plus the fur makes it more difficult to clean.
This is a great anal toy for those who are interested in the furry lifestyle without going all out on a full costume. The plug is somewhat small, so it is best for beginners who are new to this type of play. It can be a fun option for both men and women, so you can spice up your bedroom activities in a variety of ways. This butt plug and tail combo is also quite cheap for those who don’t want to spend a fortune on their sex toys.
What do we love it for?
The furry tail is soft and pretty
The materials used won’t irritate sensitive skin
The slim neck and flared base keep it firmly in place
The plug is a good size for beginners
What were we disappointed with?
The tail prevents this toy from being used for water play
The fur makes it a bit hard to clean
Things to Consider
Metal butt plugs are not a new thing, though they are a favorite among those who are into anal play. These toys are sturdy, with some weight to them, giving you a fuller feeling with even the smaller toys. They are also durable, comfortable, and easy to use, with a variety of sizes and styles available to try out. For more information on what to look for in a metal butt plug, check out our buying guide below.
Benefits of Metal Anal Plugs
The best butt plugs on the market can be made of a variety of materials, including silicone, glass, and plastic but few have as many benefits as metal toys. Metal is durable and firm, so it won’t bend or break, even with regular use.
Many of the metals used, like stainless steel, aluminum, or titanium, are also rust-proof, so you won’t need to worry about any corrosion destroying your favorite anal toy. Metal butt plugs are also made of one solid piece, with no nooks and crannies to collect fluids or dirt, making them easy to clean.
Best way to use butt plugs
With metal anal plug, you should put a generous amount of lube to ensure safety
Those who have never used an anal plug may not know the best ways to use them, so we’re here to help. First, use a generous amount of lubricant. This will ensure that the toy can be inserted comfortably without causing any pain or damage to your anal cavity.
Start with a small toy, easing it in and getting used to how it feels. Don’t try to wear your plug for too long at first, either. Start with a few minutes, then work your way up to longer sessions. The average time recommended by medical professionals is 2 to 3 hours.
Of course, some do wear them much longer, so if you’re interested in trying this out, one of the best all-day butt plugs may be a good choice. You can also work your way up to larger plugs, as long as you are still comfortable with a bigger toy.
How to Pick the Best Metal Butt Plugs
When choosing a new metal butt plug, there are a few features that you should consider before purchasing one. The following sections can help you pick the perfect toy.
Metal type
Metal butt plugs can be made of a few different metals. Stainless steel, like the material used for the Aneros Tempo, is durable and resists corrosion, so it’s a good choice. Some models do contain nickel, though, which can cause allergic reactions in some people, so try to avoid these if you have this allergy.
Aluminum is another good option since it is also strong, lightweight, and easy to clean, plus it won’t rust.
Circumference
The circumference of the toy refers to the size of the bulbed end that you would insert inside you. Smaller anal toys have a circumference of 2 to 3 inches, making them a great choice for newbies. We also recommend the best beginner butt plugs if you’re looking for something different to try. Advanced toys can be as large as 5 inches, like the Nexus Cestos. You can also try a set, like the Lovehoney Jewelled Metal Butt Plug Set, which includes 3 different sizes for you to work your way through.
Insertable length
Many metal butt plugs are rather compact and fit for beginner users
The insertable length tells you how far inside you the toy can extend. This can range from 2.5 to 4 inches when you check the models in our reviews. Beginners may prefer one that doesn’t extend too far inside while more experienced users may be able to handle a longer toy.
Designs
There are several designs available, from straight toys with a single bulb on the end to those with multiple bulbs for increased pleasure. There are also curved toys that can hit that P-spot perfectly. Some toys even have rings on the ends for easy grasping, jewels for an eye-catching shine, or a tail to add some animalistic fun to your bedroom activities.
Knobs and ribs
Many metal butt plugs include extra knobs or ribbing along the shaft. This extra texturing allows for more stimulation along the sensitive nerve endings in your anal cavity. They increase the pleasure, so you even get more enjoyment from a shorter session.
Flared base
Make sure your metal anal plug comes with flared base that prevents the toy from getting stuck inside
A flared base on an anal plug helps to keep the toy from getting sucked into your anus while you’re wearing it. The larger the base, the less likely this occurrence, though you don’t want it to be too large or it may not be comfortable to wear. The njoy Pure Plug even adds a ring on its base to make it even easier to grab when inserting or removing the toy.
Extra features
Butt plugs have few extras beyond the features we’ve discussed above, though there are a few to watch for. The Nexus Cestos includes an internal vibrator and remote control to change the settings. It is also rechargeable using a magnetic USB cord for added convenience. There could also be some fun extras, like jeweled bases or tails to add some style and fun to your toy.
Whether or not they can rust depends on the type of material and how you care for the anal plug. Stainless steel and aluminum are both rust-proof, so you shouldn’t need to worry about rust. If the toy is made of a metal that can rust, as long as you clean it well and dry it thoroughly before storage, rust shouldn’t be an issue.
Stainless steel butt plugs can be cleaned using gentle soap and warm water. Wash away all the fluids and other debris that has collected on the plug. Dry it thoroughly and store it in a bag or box until you’re ready to use it again.
Our Verdict
All of the metal butt plugs in our reviews are high-quality and fun to use, though we do have a few favorites that we preferred.
Our top model is the Aneros Tempo, which is made of medical-grade stainless steel, with a weighted head and a flared base. It can be used by both men and women, plus it is waterproof and temperature-sensitive. It also includes a satin-lined storage box.
The Nexus Cestos is a ribbed stainless steel toy with a built-in vibrator that offers 6 models to choose from that can be controlled using the handy remote control. This toy is also rechargeable using the magnetic USB cord.
For those on a budget, the best metal butt plugs may be the Lovehoney Jewelled Metal Butt Plug Set. It includes 3 toys of varying sizes and weights, all of which are stainless steel with jeweled bases that look as good as they feel.
References
1.
Metal Hypersensitivity - Causes, Symptoms, Treatment, Diagnosis - MedBroadcast.com
Metal hypersensitivity is a disorder of the immune system. It is a common condition that affects 10% to 15% of the population. It can produce a variety of symptoms, including rashes, swelling, or pain due to contact with certain metals (see the symptoms and complications section, below).
Anal plugs and retrograde colonic irrigation are helpful in fecal incontinence or constipation - PMC
AIM: To evaluate the feasibility, clinical effect and predicting factors for favorable outcome of treatment with anal plugs in fecal incontinence and retrograde colonic irrigation (RCI) in patients with fecal incontinence or constipation.
