Hi - I'm Martha! I'm a journalist and product tester at JoyNights. I love to share my ideas and personal sex life experience so that others can learn from my experiences.
read more
Hi - I'm Doris! I've spent decades working in the adult industry, including at several sex toy manufacturers as well as a large brick & mortar sex shop. I love reviewing read more
Last updated: February 27, 2024
JoyNights is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here
If you want to delve into anal play a fun and safe starting point is butt plugs. The anal area consists of pleasurable nerve endings. And there is nothing wrong about discovering a new erotic region. Fortunately, there are plugs ideal for beginners and advanced users as well. But picking the best beginner butt plug can be confusing due to several brands out there. But what makes a high-quality butt plug stands out?
And what should you be looking for to identify the best product? As a beginner, you might feel shy or confused about what to pick. Some plugs aren’t safe for anal play, so you need to be aware of what to look out for. We’ve reviewed the top butt plugs for beginners. We’ve also highlighted key features such as material, insertable length, flexibility, and circumference. This is to help you have a seamless process picking a plug. We also considered the price to ensure you don’t break your bank to have pleasure.
More features: submersible, phthalate, and latex-free, 80 min run time on a full charge, 6 vibration modes, ribbed neck
Nexus Ace is a small, quiet vibrating butt plug designed with you in mind. The plug features a tapered tip to offer smooth insertion. With a ribbed neck, you’re assured of streamlined stimulation. This is a remote-controlled product where you or your partner can control the 6 vibration functions. Meaning you can choose the level that will amps up your sensation. If you’re not comfortable, you can start from level one and proceed as you master the tips and tricks of using it.
The Ace enjoys a whisper-quiet, 8-meter remote range operation. It means you can quietly enjoy your moments without causing some commotions. The USB magnetic charging enables you to charge it anywhere. The silicone casing and 6 distinct modes of vibration are meant to give you remarkable anal play experience. An 80-minute charge provides 80 minutes run time.
When it comes to butt plugs, a stable base is quite crucial. And that’s why the Ace is designed with a flared base for optimal stimulation and peace of mind. The silicone material is safe for your anal. It’s latex-free, which is ideal for people with sensitive skin.
What stands out? The Nexus Ace is latex-free and phthalate-free, making it an ideal butt plug for people with sensitive skin. It’s also submersible.
What cons did we manage to find? The plug could be a bit flexible. However, this may not stop you from climaxing.
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 9340 people in the past 30 days
9.6
Customer Feedback
Based on cross-platform reviews
9.4
Brand Reputation
Based on web analytics & content of negative reviews
More features: anal douche included, lubricant applicator included, vibrating plug with 6 patterns, travel bag included, splash-proof, phthalate and latex-free
If you want to venture into the backdoor play, the b-Vibe Rechargeable Anal Training and Education Butt Plug Set is the best place to begin. It’s ideal for people who seek a little variety when it comes to sizes and shapes. The all-in-one kit ushers you into a thrilling world of anal play. And you don’t have to struggle on which item is for what. The kit comes with a detailed education guide that comes with three body-safe silicone butt plugs.
Most people would have heard packing their toys while travelling. After all, you shouldn’t let people notice your erotic business. Luckily, these butt plugs come in a sturdy box with a black zippered travel case. Besides concealing your toys, the case prevents the products from getting dirt. Each plug features and tapered shape with a flexible slim neck, ready to bring pleasure to your posterior. The flared base is for ultimate comfort and peace of mind.
For starting, uses the smallest plug, which 4 inches long and 3.25 inches in circumference. Once you master anal play, you can progress to the medium plug that features 6 vibration patterns. It’s 5.5 inches long and 4 inches in circumference.
What are its best features? the all-in-one 5-piece anal kit comes with a detailed guide to train you on the posterior game.
What could be improved? If it could give more girth, the set would be more enthralling.
Your ass or that of your partner deserves gentle treatment. Treat it with the utmost respect and love it. You can achieve this using njoy Pure Plug. Your first steps into the anal pleasure will be enthralling. This luxurious metal butt plug features an erotically bulbed head, wide finger loop, and smooth curves for safe use.
The njoy Pure Plug adds a touch of elegance and class to your toy box. It’s designed to deliver smooth, sensual sensations during anal. The feeling reassuringly heavy at 140 grams. This plug is perfectly shaped with a slim step and angled head for easy insertion and to touch on all sensual corners. The large flared base sits comfortably outside the body, offering premium safety and comfort.
Cast in 316-grade stainless steel is hand-polished to a mirror shine, which is absolutely smooth and non-porous. If you want extra sensations, heat the plug or cool in warm water, but avoid putting it in a freezer.
Coat your toy with a slick lubricant just before you press into the body for a smooth slide. Allow the bulbed head to stimulate your erotic points and make you climax.
The package arrives in a stunning presentation case to allow you to carry it with confidence and pride.
What makes it stand out? The njoy Pure Plug is a stunning, stainless steel plug, explicitly designed to stimulate your erotic points.
Which disadvantages must you keep in mind? The plug could be a little bit flexible for easy adjustments.
More features: 3 speeds and 7 vibration patterns, 112 grams weight, submersible, phthalate, and latex-free, USB rechargeable
Having anal play should not be an expensive affair, especially if you’re a beginner. The Tracey Cox Supersex is a rechargeable vibrating plug designed to deliver a sensational feeling. It has three speeds combined with seven patterns to gives you endless choices to enjoy a posterior game. Start with speed level one and progress slowly. The tapered tip makes it easy to insert the plug in your butt.
Exploring anal play should be sensational and comfortable. You can also try double penetration and experience a whole lot of excitement. This small silicone, a rechargeable butt plug is perfect for couples and solo sex. This toy weighs 112 grams and is designed with a thick, stable T-bar base. You can place the plug on a flat surface and enjoy a ride hands-free.
The Tracey Cox Supersex butt plug is fully waterproof. Meaning you can enjoy it in the shower, bath, and even in a swimming pool. It features an inset button that prevents unexpected mode changes.
For smooth and safe penetration, coat the plug with a lubricant. It’s made of silicone, which is anal-friendly material. The phthalate and latex-free plug is perfect for all skin types.
What do we love it for? The Tracey Cox Supersex is endowed with 3 speeds and 7 patterns to give the user a wide range of selections.
What were we disappointed with? Changing the setting could have been easier if done with a remote.
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 2440 people in the past 30 days
9.3
Customer Feedback
Based on cross-platform reviews
9.0
Brand Reputation
Based on web analytics & content of negative reviews
More features: splash-proof, latex and phthalate-free, textured body, 90-degree plug-in point
If you want your exploration into the anal sex world, ElectraStim Bi-Polar Electrosex will serve your purpose. You can stimulate yourself or use it together with your parent. Rock and roll all night or even during the day with a sensational butt plug for beginners. It’s engineered with a tapered, texture body.
It will drive your backdoor crazy and wild. This great product is for both sexes and ideal for prolonged wear. Insert the plug and relax as you enjoy being tickled by its magnificent girth. The 4-inch insertable product creates a fulfilling sensation, while the long neck smooth curves ensure wear is safe and comfortable.
You have nothing to worry about if you have sensitive skin since the plug is latex and phthalate-free. The splashproof gadget boasts 90-degree plug-in points. It means you can use it while seated. Try gradually lowering yourself onto the tip and rock back and forth to experiment with various stimulations.
Slather the plug efficiently with water-based lubricant or anal lube for safe anal penetration. 4-inch insertable length with 3.75-inch girth will is perfect for beginners.
Why are we impressed? The ElectraStim Bi-Polar Electrosex butt plug is designed to suit both sexes. The flared base offers comfortable prolonged wear. The 90-degree cable entry will enable you to use the toy in a seated position.
What negatives must you be aware of? A storage or carrying case could have made it easy to carry the plug.
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 3004 people in the past 30 days
9.0
Customer Feedback
Based on cross-platform reviews
8.9
Brand Reputation
Based on web analytics & content of negative reviews
More features: 18.5 in long tail, splashproof, latex and phthalate-free, 3.3 oz weight
Take your anal stimulation to the next level with DOMINIX Deluxe Small Faux. Do you think your butt deserves some little enticement? The Deluxe butt plug will look superb on your ass. Waggle it with pride as you experience excellent stimulation sessions. The splashproof plug is 18.5 inches long.
The product has a 2.5-inch insertable length, which is perfectly fine for beginners. The experienced vixens also find this plug satisfying. It has a girth of 3.5 inches, making you feel fuller back there for climaxing. You can insert it and relax in your bed for as long as you wish.
If you’re worried about carrying it, you have nothing to be anxious about. It’s a lightweight plug weighing 3.3oz and is foldable into a compact package. The stainless steel material is temperature-responsive, smooth for safe insertion, and durable. The slim neck and flared base give you unmatched comfort.
If you want to enjoy it fully, coat the plug with anal lubricant. This will prevent friction, eliminating painful anal play.
People with sensitive skin find it hard to get butt plugs that suit them. Fortunately, DOMINIX Deluxe Small Faux is designed to offer peace of mind. It’s phthalate and latex-free, making it sensitive-skin friendly.
What makes it stand out? DOMINIX Deluxe Small Faux will make you go-round as a stunning, sexy fox for your partner. The tail is of good quality and incredibly soft.
Which disadvantages must you keep in mind? It would have been more enticing if the tail was a little bit longer.
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 3505 people in the past 30 days
8.8
Customer Feedback
Based on cross-platform reviews
8.5
Brand Reputation
Based on web analytics & content of negative reviews
More features: latex and phthalate-free, submersible, tips with pressure release holes, smooth shaft
Butt play has never been this exciting. The Size Matters Magnum will dial your backdoor with style and tons of pleasure. The 5 butt plugs set is designed to help beginners start small and work their way up to satisfying ranks.
Beginners will love the ambitious 3.5-inch insertable length. And as you grow in confidence, you can push your pleasure limits to higher heights. You can do this alone or ask your partner to help. These plugs are made of sturdy plastic with pressure release holes to avoid the build-up of internal pressure for total safety. Internal pressure will cause discomfort and pain, running what could have been pleasurable moments.
The tapered head is easy for insertion. The plugs have flared bases and long shafts, allowing you to wear it for long hours without moving or shifting. The insertable length ranges from 3.5 to 5.1 inches.
Do you want to have your butt play in a shower, bath, or even a swimming pool? Size Matters Magnum got your back. The plugs are waterproof to enable you to enjoy your posterior moments anywhere. The phthalate and latex-free products are gentle on all skin types.
Why are we impressed? The Size Matters Magnum is made of hard plastic, which is easy to insert. Beginners can start small and progress to expert users.
What negatives must you be aware of? The price may be a little higher for most novices to afford. However, it’s worth it.
More features: waterproof, USB rechargeable, phthalate, and latex-free
The list could not be complete without mentioning Mantric Rechargeable Vibrating Butt Plug. Combining a powerful motor, ergonomic design, and luxury material make this plug the best bet for beginners. The design spells comfort and peace of mind. Enjoy a smooth insertion that stays in place for long. Thanks to the teardrop body and long neck.
Having pleasurable posterior moments should be a private affair. The whisper-quiet vibrations will enable you to enjoy butt play sessions without your next-door neighbor noticing. Not to mention it’s a fully waterproof product for fun in the shower and tub.
You won’t struggle in keeping the plug clean. The USB rechargeable plug ensures you have nice moments anytime you want. Coat your toy generously with high-quality water-based lube for safe and smooth insertion. The color-changing panel offers more fun, which changes with each setting.
With variation speeds and patterns, you can easily choose what you want. The plug is made from silicone, easy to clean, durable, and safe for your butt.
What are our favorite features? Mantric Rechargeable Vibrating Butt Plug is a rechargeable toy that’s packaged consciously. The plug has strong vibrations, which you can use on both ends.
What could be better? The buttons could have been a little more oversized for easy control of vibrations. It could be better with a remote controller.
Things to Consider
If you want to delve into the joy of butt plugs, you’re in the right place. These products allow you to enjoy posterior stimulation regardless of orientation, genitalia, or gender. Not to mention that booty is surrounded by nerve endings.
The best beginner butt plug can help you explore new sexual territory with comfort and safety. whatever reason you want to dive into anal sex, there are a few things to pay attention to. Follow this guide for detailed information.
What you need to start using butt plugs
Although it took ages to get here, butt plugs are finally getting a fair share in the sex industry. Anal fingering and rimming are still popular. However, for people who want a dedicated anal play, a plug becomes an ultimate choice.
When used correctly, butt plugs can be incredibly pleasurable for both men and women. in case you don’t know, your booty has tons of nerve endings that need to get stimulated. With a plug, you can experience more and better orgasms.
However, like various products on the market, butt plugs come in all sizes, shapes, and materials. as a beginner, start small and work your way up. The best thing about these toys is that they can’t get stuck or lost inside you. Meaning you’re always safe using them.
To start using a butt plug, you need to have a strong desire for anal sex. You cannot force anal penetration, lest you fracture your rectum. Secondly, you must choose the perfect size to start with. Typically, start small and progress step by step. You may ask your partner to help you insert the plug until the time you gain the confidence to do so.
More so, you need lots of lube and patience to hack the art of posterior play.
Safety tips for butt plug users
Anal penetration has met different concerns and worries. Even after becoming a pro, there might be medical conditions that might happen during your life. Some people bleed, while others develop discomfort and pain.
Even if you don’t have specific concerns, there are general rules of using a butt plug, especially for a beginner.
You should always use lube
Be patient with yourself
Learn how to insert and remove plugs safely
Start small and progress up to the ranks
When it comes to butt plugs, cleanliness becomes an urgent priority
You can also develop an allergic reaction for using a butt plug. It can be caused by the lube, plug, or the tail. Therefore, be cautious when you’re choosing your toy. The material used can also contribute to these severe reactions.
When choosing a butt plug, consider material such as glass, stainless steel, and silicone. Picking phthalate and latex-free plugs will save you the discomfort and pain caused by allergy reactions. You should also be more cautious about lubes. Make sure you check the ingredients used to avoid inflammations.
There are also tail related allergies. Tails are mostly made of polyester or nylon. So, if you’re allergic to these materials, keep off tailed plugs.
Another significant concern is bleeding issues. Well, this is perfectly normal as you start. The plugs may cause a tiny tear that should heal naturally. Sometimes bleeding might be due to lack of enough lubrication or using a larger toy that your booty can accommodate. You can try adding more lubes and staring small. If this doesn’t work, it’s advisable to take a break. Figure things out and maybe start it later.
Butt plugs also get stuck, but it’s a rare occasion. But muscles are designed to push poop out of the body. However, they can also suck things in. a good case is the use of suppositories. The butt will grip onto the grip tightly, especially as a beginner.
Once the toy is sucked in, it can travel deeper into the anal canal and all the way to the colon. This will necessitate surgery. To avoid such mishaps, always use a plug with a flared base. This is to ensure the product doesn’t go in any farther than it’s recommended.
Sharing butt plugs is also a major concern. But you’re strongly advised against it wherever possible. Butts are full bacteria. Some are good, while others are harmful and nasty. You should also avoid inserting it in your ass and then into your vagina at the same time.
A butt plug can bring you immeasurable pleasure. But if misused, you may end up with tons of regrets.
Price range
Butt plugs for beginners come at all shapes and prices. But most manufacturers consider the price factor for beginners, making them as affordable as possible. The price range can lie between $20 to about $100.
But sometimes, you might be forced to pay more, based on what you want. Avoid extremely low-priced plugs since most of them are made of cheap, flimsy materials. You’d rather save for longer than picking just any available toy. Your butt deserves love, respect, and care.
Features to consider while buying the best beginner butt plug
Picking the best beginner butt plug can be unnerving. Thanks to an array of products on the market. Many brands are cropping up in all manner of toys. You should then be extra cautious when making a choice.
You can only pick the right plug if you know what you’re looking for. Consider these factors for the right product.
Material
Unlike different designs, some materials are not safe. There are better and safe ones, while some should be emphatically avoided.
Metal – This is a common material used in designing butt plugs. It gives the toy an elegant look with enhanced durability. njoy Pure Plug is a stainless-steel butt plug that can last you for years. When made correctly, stainless steel plugs can be smooth for easy insertion. Metal is a temperature-responsive material, meaning it will be cold when you start using it, though it will gain some heat once you insert it.
Silicone– This is the most popular material for most sex toys, butt plug included. Some of the plugs include ElectraStim Bi-Polar Electrosex and Nexus Ace, just to mention a few. Silicone butt plugs have a velvety texture that feels good against the skin. It’s non-porous, 100% skin safe, and easy to clean. From rechargeable to battery-operated, the silicone butt plugs are durable and skin-safe.
Hard plastic – Butt plugs made of hard plastic such as Size Matters Magnum are generally smooth and easy to clean. These toys are quite affordable, but they may not last long compared to stainless steel, glass, or silicone counterparts.
Jelly Rubber – This material is incredibly soft, but it can be floppy. However, they may contain toxic ingredients, which might harm your body. If possible, avoid plugs made from this material.
Circumference
Are you ready for butt pleasure? Then having a butt plug is a great way to start. Plugs are cleverly manufactured to stay put. But not everything one should fit in your butt. They also start in small sizes and graduate at a comfortable level.
The smooth, seamless material and tapered head create an easy insertion. When it comes to measurement, the circumference will either give you a tight or loose girth. But since you’re a beginner, it’s advisable to start small and graduate progressively. A small plug can range between 2.5 to 3.0 inches. On the upper hand, it can be 5 inches.
The circumference helps you in opening the anus for a bigger toy or to accommodate a penis. Whatever you want, ensure you start with a small plug and avoid hurting yourself.
Insertable length
The insertable length will depend on how deep you want the plug to be in your butt. And just like circumference, go slow on it. The range may start from 2.5 inches, such as DOMINIX Deluxe Small Faux.
With time, your butt will be able to swallow a whole 5 or 6 inches. But before that, take great caution but applying lube, using a shorter plug, and being patient with yourself.
Vibration option
When you’re looking for double fun, get a vibrating plug like Mantric Rechargeable Vibrating Butt Plug. There are various vibration options which you can choose using a button or a remote. In most cases, there can be about speed options.
As a novice, start with level 1 and gradually climb the rank. The vibrating plugs are rechargeable to keep you entertained whenever you want. Therefore, when choosing such plugs, ensure it has a decent run time and a long-lasting battery.
Also, choose how you want to control the speed- using a button or remote. Essentially, remote-controlled plugs are much easier to use compared to the button counterparts.
Flexibility
Flexibility gives you comfort and superior pleasure. But as for a beginner, get a firm or rigid plug to enable you to insert the product smoothly. At this point, you might not be in a position to move in different positions.
You can insert the product and stay with it the entire day without shifting or moving. With a rigid plug that has a flared base, you can put it on a flat surface and enjoy hands-free anal pleasurable moments.
Durability
A butt plug is an enticing toy that will give you pleasurable moments. Your butt will hold it tightly, and for this reason, avoid buying that may break insider your booty. There are cons out there who advertise plugs, but they’re not as durable they opt to be. That’s why you should stick with reliable brands for high-quality items.
The material used will determine the durability of your plug. Stainless steel is the most reliable material. It’s smooth and durable as well. Maintaining metal plugs is also easy. But when it’s not well maintained, it might be harmful. Always clean it before and after use and store in a cool, dry place. Perhaps you should invest in a plug that comes with a storage/carrying cases.
Silicon is also a durable material that is so soft to the skin. Glass plugs follow it. Glass plugs are made of special glass that cannot break. These plugs are stunning and work with a variety of lubes.
When purchasing, ensure you inquire about the material used to be sure your plug will last you for long.
Waterproof
Nothing beats the feeling of having an anal play wherever you want. It could be in your bed, shower, or your private swimming pool. There are many waterproof plugs on the market to consider.
Tracey Cox Supersex is 100% waterproof, meaning you can use it in the shower. However, most tailed plugs are not waterproof. So, know which plug to use in water and which to avoid. Essentially, it should be indicated on the label the waterproof degree.
Allergen-free
Unfortunately, you can get butt plug allergies. This is mostly caused by the material used. Phthalates and latex are toxic to your skin. High exposure to these toxic materials has been linked to cancer. Some people will get inflammation, which is undoubtedly painful.
Many jelly and hard plastic butt plugs contain phthalates as an ingredient. These soft materials might break down in your body, leading to phthalate or latex exposures through the sensitive, thing anal lining.
There is no known the right quantity of phthalate or latex one should get exposed to. To be on the safer side, it’s advisable to avoid any product with these toxic elements.
That’s why you should consider buying phthalate and latex-free butt plugs. Such plugs are suitable for all types of skins. Some tails might also give you an allergic reaction. Be careful when choosing such products.
It’s for your good to use a safe and clean butt plug. It doesn’t matter how clean your rectum is; the fact is the botty if full of harmful and nasty bacteria. Meaning, your butt plug will have some residual of these bacteria.
Porous plugs are made of Cyberskin, nylon, rigid plastic, jelly, rubber, and neoprene. For such plugs, use lukewarm water and mild soap. And ensure you clean them immediately after use. Failure to do so, the bacterial will crawl inside, making your plug unsafe for insertion.
For non-porous material such as stainless steel, glass, and silicon, you can submerge them in boiling water and leave them to cool. Alternatively, use lukewarm water and mild soap.
If your plug has an animal tail, first know if its real or faux fur. For real fur, don’t submerge it into water. Instead, use damped cloth and gently dab the tail. Use a hair-dryer to dry it. For the faux fur tail, you can submerge it in water and wash it gently with soap.
Yes, you can. This happens when you use it wrongly. If you buy a bigger plug that your booty can swallow, you’ll definitely hurt the anal lining. More so, failure to use enough lubrication will cause the tearing of the anus lining. You should be careful about how you go about anal sex.
The butt muscles are designed to puss things out. However, these muscles can also suck in the stuff inside your body. And when sucked, you may struggle to get the item out. And the worst scenario is when the product travels deep into the colon.
That’s is you’re advised to use a plug with a flared base. It means the plug will not go past the butt hole. And you can wear them for a long time.
Our Verdict
Our first pick is the Nexus Ace butt plug. The toy is designed with a tapered tip and ribbed neck to amps up sensation. It has 6 vibration functions that are easily controlled by a remote. The whisper-quiet operation allows you to enjoy your posterior moments without causing a commotion. It’s a rechargeable plug with a run time of 80 minutes.
Our third pick is njoy Pure Plug. This stainless-steel plug introduces you to the pleasurable world of anal sex in style. It features an erotically bulbed head, smooth curves, and a large flared base for comfort. 2.5 insertable inches and 3.0-inch girt is suitable for beginners. The smooth metal finish is easy to clean and maintain.
