Hi - I'm Edgar! I'm a journalist and a product tester for JoyNights. I get paid to play with sex toys and tell you what they're like - it's the best job ever 😊
Please read more
Hi - I'm Justin! I've spent decades working on adult film sets, and also over a decade consulting for sex toy manufacturers. I love testing and reviewing cutting edge sexual read more
Last updated: October 16, 2023
JoyNights is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here
Are you looking to step up to a higher level of anal play? Ever fantasized about anal sex but are scared of stretching your butt? An anal stretcher will gradually stretch your ass so that you can comfortably take in your anal toys or even a penis. That said, it is important to find the best anal stretcher for your body.
We’ve done the job for you and reviewed 11 products. We made our own list of the 5 best anal stretchers, with the Size Matters Magnum Ease-In Anal Dilator Kit being our top pick. On the list, you’ll find anal plugs which stretch a butt in a gentle manner and are comfortable even during sex, dilators that are smooth and easy for penetration, or inflated stretchers that can be inserted and inflated while inside the anus. We also included stretchers made of the safest high-quality materials like silicone, latex, or PVC.
"Fairly priced anal stretcher in a shape of penis that can be inflated to a comfortable size.12 in max circumference.7 in insertable length.Submersible."
More features: 5 plugs, submersible, allergen-free, rigid
Are you new to anal sex and want to train your booty beforehand? With Size Matters Magnum Ease-In Anal Dilator Kit, you get five butt plugs ranging from the mini to the extra large size. This set allows you to start from the mini plug and work your way up as you see fit. Once you get accustomed to using this set of anal stretchers, you can move to bigger and better sex toys.
These anal stretchers have a rounded head and a pointed tip that makes penetration easy. It is also quite firm in texture, which not only helps to stretch your arm but also maintain the butt hole for long. Moreover, these lovely anal stretchers come with a small hole at the top to ease any pressure arising during insertion.
Size Matters Magnum Ease-In Anal Dilator Kit is also easy to use as it does not present any complications. All you may have to do is simply find a nice lubricant and you will experience maximum pleasure. What’s more? Cleaning this anal stretcher is quite easy and proper maintenance will ensure you use it for long.
What we liked: The different sizes ensure that you can find a comfortable butt plug without having to overstretch your booty. They are made of durable materials and can be cleaned easily.
What could be better: A smoother and more flexible material would improve user experience
More features: curved shape, finger loop, firm, submersible, allergen-free
Some people find anal play to be quite uncomfortable or even just painful. But with the right set of anal dilators, you can train your body to make penetration easier. Inspire Silicone Dilator Training Set allows you to stretch your tight anus for maximum comfort and pleasure.
Whether you are new to anal sex or simply want to try out new sex toys, this dilator training set will gently ease you in. The set comes with 5 silicone protractors that will give you some pleasurable anal play, at your own pace. Each of the five dildos is tapered and has smooth edges for a comfortable insertion. Moreover, the set allows you to expand your comfort zone as you move from the small size to the large one.
Using this silicone dilator training set is quite easy too. We recommend that you purchase a water-based lubricant for your anal play sessions. All you have to do is apply the lubricant both on your toy and your booty then apply some gentle pressure to insert the dildo. You should also ensure that you master one dilator at a time before progressing to the next one.
What we liked: This dilator set has been designed with tapered silicone, which is gentle on your booty. Great for beginners.
What could be better: The finger loop at the base means they are not safe for use as a butt plug.
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 5293 people in the past 30 days
9.5
Customer Feedback
Based on cross-platform reviews
9.2
Brand Reputation
Based on web analytics & content of negative reviews
More features: rounded tip, hand pump, phthalate-free, submersible, flexible
The Cock Locker Inflatable Penis Butt Plug is the perfect introduction to anyone that would love some anal fun. It features an inflatable butt plug that takes the shape of a veiny penis. The inflatable dildo is made from phthalate-free latex, which means that it is allergen-free.
This inflatable butt plug is great for those who want to step up their anal play slowly. It inflates from 5 inches to about 12 inches in girth depending on your comfort zone. Moreover, it has a realistic tip and a veiny shaft to resemble a real penis.
Using this inflatable butt plug is also a walk in the park. All you need to do is to apply a water-based lubricant on the stretcher and on your anus. Insert the rounded tip and squeeze the pump till you get to the right size. A simple release mechanism is fitted on top of the pump that you can use to deflate the anal stretcher.
Cleaning this anal stretcher is not difficult. This is made easy by its waterproof capabilities as you can submerge the dildo during cleaning. You can also use it while you are showering.
What we liked: The veiny shaft and rounded tip makes Cock Locker Inflatable Penis Butt Plug a realistic penis.
What could be better: While this butt plug looks realistic, its latex material does not look too durable.
One of the first things that you notice about the Perfect Fit Tunnel Anal Plug is its appealing design. Coming in a black or clear color, this anal plug will help you take your anal play to the next level. It takes a flexible and malleable shape that is guaranteed to fulfill your darkest pleasures.
As it says on the package, this anal plug is specifically designed for extreme naughtiness. Its unique feature is its integrated tunnel that you can use in several ways. For example, you can use the tunnel to lube your ass, insert fingers or even use your vibrator if it’s the larger size.
Perfect Fit Tunnel Anal Plug is made from flexible rubber, which is both comfortable to wear as a butt plug or to use during anal play. The flared base also ensures that it is safe to use the toy as a butt plug. Moreover, the clear rubber material gives your partner some great visuals when you are using it.
If you are an intermediate in anal play then this can be a great addition to your sex toys. Its one-inch diameter may be too huge for beginners but advanced users can easily take it in.
What we liked: The ability to use this tunnel butt plug with any lube means you will not have to invest in a new lubricant.
What could be better: It would be great if it was waterproof
More features: phthalate-free, flared base, tapered tip, harness compatible, submersible
Doc Johnson Titanmen is a ribbed anal stretcher that is designed to help you build resilience and stamina. It works great for intermediate and experienced bottoms that would like to step up their anal play. That said, beginners can also use it if they have some little experience. Moreover, you can use it as a butt plug or an anal stretcher because of its conical shape.
This is the perfect anal stretcher is you are looking to train for a bigger toy or a penis. It is tapered smoothly around its surface to ensure that it easily slides in your booty. The conical shape of this anal stretcher also comes in handy. You will notice that the butt plug widens at just the right angle to ensure you are not uncomfortable or experience pain when pushing it in. You can start with the first ring and proceed all the way to the fifth ring as you deem fit.
With regards to material, Doc Johnson Titanmen is made from phthalate-free PVC. This means that you can easily clean it using warm water or a suitable toy care liquid. It is, however, worth noting that this toy may attract dust or hairs so you should not clean it with any material that sheds fiber.
What we liked: The conical shape and tapered head allows you to progress from one level to the other without pain or discomfort.
What could be better: A firmer material would ensure that it does not bend when you use it in the wrong position.
Things to Consider
Anal stretching is a great way to enlarge your anal opening a few sizes at a time if you want to step up your anal play game. With a good anal stretcher, a couple can receive intense sexual stimulation, especially the recipient. Whether you are a novice or expert in anal play, a stretcher will offer you your much desired sexual pleasure while preparing you for anal stimulation. But first things first. How do you find the best anal stretcher?
How to properly use anal stretchers
There are several reasons why people are into anal stretching. For some, it is just some kink that gives them sexual pleasure when their booty is stretched beyond their comfort zone. Other people use anal stretchers to modify their butts. If you are into anal play then you may have noticed that some people’s anus looks different after regular anal stimulation. This is not necessarily a bad thing. You can use an anal stretcher in this way if you are into body modification. Anal gaping is also another reason why you should get an anal stretcher, if you are into that sort of thing. Gaping is when your anus is wide open and this can be pleasurable for some or a precursor to some mind-blowing anal sex. Despite your reasons for getting an anal stretcher, here are some tips to help you use it properly;
Know your body- It is important that you understand your pleasure and pain points before you get into this advanced activity. You may want to experiment with your fingers and other sex toys first. Experiencing sexual pleasure from booty may be a totally new experience and you may want to know your body before you start anal stretching.
Have everything ready before anal play– Like most forms of solo play, you may want to get everything ready beforehand. Some of the common things you may need include a puppy pad, all your toys, paper towels, lubricant, and a washcloth if necessary. Remember to also bring out all your erotic content too, if you need it.
Lubrication– It is important to lubricate your toy thoroughly before you begin any form of anal play. It is even more important to lubricate your toy and booty when anal stretching. Make sure you use the right amount of lube (depending on your anal stretcher) and don’t be scared to use lots of it.
Take it slowly– Once the toy is well lubricated, you can proceed to insert it slowly. Ensure that you take it slowly and that your body is relaxed. Your body will stretch beyond its limits if you are in a warm and cozy mental and physical environment. Being aroused helps too! Unlike anal sex where the size of the penis is constant, anal stretchers get enlarged at the base. Slowly slide in the anal stretcher until you feel pressure and let the toy rest.
Wiggle the toy and feel free to orgasm– Once your body has reached its limit, you can wiggle the anal stretcher to feel pleasure. You can also slowly pull out and insert the toy back to the same depth for pleasure. After that you are free to orgasm or save your sexual energy for another time.
Safety tips for butt stretching
It is not uncommon to push your body to new limits when exploring some new kinks. And you can also go overboard with anal stretching.
One of the biggest risk of anal play or stretching is developing microtears on your anus. Having these tears exposes your body to infections even if you clean your toys thoroughly. To avoid this, do not head into anal sex too quickly and take your time before you go all out. There is also a danger of hemorrhoids if you stretch you anal muscles beyond its limit too soon.
Never ignore any sharp pain that you experience when stretching your anus. Back off immediately you experience any sharp pain. If your body feels better after that then you can resume your anal play. However, you should stop if you still feel some tinge of pain after resting for some time. Anal stretching gives you some intense feelings but you should never tolerate any sharp pain. Experiencing this sharp pain is the way your body tells you that you have gone too far.
Avoid anal stretching when you experience soreness for several days. Although a bit of soreness is normal after a day or two of anal play, anything after this may mean you went too far. If this happens, just take a rest for a couple of days before resuming your stretching routine.
Lastly, never expedite your anal stretching routine. Don’t do it too quickly and you will learn your pleasure points or how your body processes stretching. After this, you can start to push your limits.
How to pick the best anal stretchers
Finding the best anal stretcher is easy when you know what to look out for before buying. Luckily, we took some time to explore some of the features that you should consider before making the final decision. These include
Type
There are different types of anal stretchers with each having their own uses and benefits. Dilators like Inspire Silicone Dilator Training Set or Size Matters Magnum Ease-In Anal Dilator Kit are quite basic. They take a tubular shape but are smooth for easy penetration. Dilators are often sold in sets of five or more stretchers of different sizes. You can start with the small size and work your way up.
Some anal stretchers take the form of a butt plug. They are often efficient since they have a narrow head and widen at the middle before tapering down. Butt plugs like Doc Johnson Titanmen are easy to insert and comfortable even during sex. The flared base prevents the dildo from being sucked in. The last thing you want is to have such an embarrassing incident at the ER. Inflatable anal stretchers like Cock Locker Inflatable Penis Butt Plug can be inserted and inflated while inside the anus.
Material
Silicone is arguably one of the safest materials that manufacturers use when making anal stretchers. Silicone toys like the Inspire Silicone Dilator Training Set are odorless, non-porous, and most importantly, hypoallergenic. A porous material is not only difficult to clean but may also foster the growth of bacteria. Other materials that are common in sex toys include ABS, latex, soft plastic, hard plastic, and PVC. Choosing the wrong material may not only be difficult to clean but it will also present some safety risks.
Girth choice
Most anal stretchers have a pretty similar shape but the girth is where things get interesting. You can choose a stretcher with the same girth throughout like Cock Locker Inflatable Penis Butt Plug. Alternatively, you can choose an anal stretcher with ranging girth. For example, the Doc Johnson Titanmen takes a conical shape with a circumference ranging from 2.5 inches to 8.5 inches.
Insertable length
With regards to insertable length, you also want an anal stretcher that you can handle. If you are a beginner then we recommend getting a stretcher with a small insertable length like the Perfect Fit Tunnel Anal Plug. You can also opt for the smallest dildo in the Inspire Silicone Dilator Training Set. If you are experienced at anal play then a stretcher with a longer insertable length like Cock Locker Inflatable Penis Butt Plug is perfect.
Allergen-free
When it comes to buying a sex toy, you should choose one that is safe for your body. It is not uncommon to find sex toys or anal stretchers made of material that may cause harm to your body. When you use a sex toy with allergens, you risk developing some allergic reactions. Luckily, many manufacturers are now making allergen-free anal stretchers that all people can use despite their allergies. Size Matters Magnum Ease-In Anal Dilator Kit is a great example of an allergen-free anal stretcher that we reviewed.
Waterproof
Would you like a waterproof or a submersible anal stretcher? If you would love to try out your anal stretcher in the bath tub then you should pick a waterproof toy like Cock Locker Inflatable Penis Butt Plug. Alternatively, you can also use a submersible plug in the shower. A waterproof sex toy is also durable as it will not likely be corroded by water.
Flexibility
If you are in the market for a sex toy then you should start with a flexible anal stretcher. Flexibility ensures that the toy will not harm you even you insert it in the wrong way or assume the wrong position during anal play. It is worth noting that the flexibility of the anal plug will most often depend on the materials used. For example, anal stretchers made from silicone or rubber are often soft and flexible. However, you can opt for a more rigid anal stretcher like the Size Matters Magnum Ease-In Anal Dilator Kit. These are often suitable for direct simulation of the G-spot/the prostate or if you crave something hard in your ass.
Quality
The overall quality of a sex toy depends on a couple of things. For example, a good quality anal stretcher should be made from a nice and safe material like silicone. It should also have smooth edges to ensure that it enters your anus without any problems. Reputable brands such as Doc Johnson are also known to create quality sex toys. Of course, this does not mean that other brands do not have quality products. Only that these popular brands have been in existence for longer and have created a reputation based on their good quality merchandise.
No. Your sphincter muscles are meant to contract and flex, which means they cannot permanently stretch. Your anus will bounce back after anus stretching.
You can dilate your asshole as wide as you feel comfortable. Remember, everyone’s stretching limit is different so you will have to find out which is the best fit for you and progress from there
Training your anus boils down to your level of comfort. Ideally, you should train your anus once or even two times a day every week for five to ten minutes. It is also recommended that you have two rest days in a week;
Once you are done, clean and sterilize your anal stretcher to avoid the infestation of bacteria. You should also take a hot bath before you proceed to other activities.
Our Verdict
Size Matters Magnum Ease-In Anal Dilator Kit is our editor’s choice, and for good reasons. This all-rounded dilator kit allows you to start with the smallest plug and work your way up. It is made of hard allergen-free plastic, is easy to use, and includes a hole at the top to ease any pressure buildup.
Our second pick is Inspire Silicone Dilator Training Set, if you don’t mind splurging on a cosy training set. It features five dildos of different sizes to help you move from novice to expert in weeks. This silicone anal stretcher set is tapered and has smooth edges for easy penetration.
Cock Locker Inflatable Penis Butt Plug is our best value pick if you want to find the best anal stretcher at an affordable price. This inflatable dildo can increase its girth from 5 inches. You will also love the veiny shaft and rounded head, which resembles an actual penis.
