Hi - I'm Edgar! I'm a journalist and a product tester for JoyNights. I get paid to play with sex toys and tell you what they're like - it's the best job ever 😊
Please read more
Hi - I'm Justin! I've spent decades working on adult film sets, and also over a decade consulting for sex toy manufacturers. I love testing and reviewing cutting edge sexual read more
Last updated: April 25, 2025
JoyNights is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here
Realistic butts are popular among individuals and couples who like their lifelike design and discrete application. However, choosing one could be a daunting task. They are available in a variety of shapes and sizes, and come with varied features meant to stimulate different areas. Also, not all the toys are made of safe, stretchy, and durable materials able to withstand hundreds of rough sex sessions.
When shopping for the best realistic butts, make sure you consider the design as well as the available openings and their depth and tightness beforehand to ensure you get the right model that will fulfill your individual desires. We came up with a list of top 6 picks, and the THRUST Pro Elite Alana Ribbed Vagina and Ass Masturbator got our Editor’s Choice nomination. All the models are great, lifelike replicas of female butts; some are hyper-realistic butts with hips and waists. There’s also a pocket butt model which you can take with you.
"Another beautifully made butt from Tantaly with 6 stimulating beads inside the vagina tunnel.33.8 inches of hips circumference.Sealed suctioning design.Drying stick is included."
"This option is probably the most realistic on the list, not only outside, but also on the inside.Realistic tunnels texture.Sealed tunnel design.36.6-inch of hips circumference."
More features: weighty and stable enough for hands-free use
THRUST Pro Elite Alana Ribbed Vagina and Ass Masturbator is a “full-scale vagina and ass masturbator” that is sure to please. It’s our editors choice for it’s looks and it’s feel. Both the ass and vagina canals look and feel amazing.
It is made of TPE devoid of phthalate. The manufacturer recommends using water-based lube for smooth entry.
The vagina is 7.5 inches in length with diameter of 0.5 inches while the anal opening is 5.5-inch long, and its diameter is a snug fit at 0.1 inches.
With a 38 inches hip and 30 inch waist measurement it’s curves feel great under your hands. Conveniently it fits a medium-sized panties and US dress size 6 to 8 so you can doll it up.
THRUST Pro Elite Alana Ribbed Vagina and Ass Masturbator comes in three skin tones. It’s sized to scale, and is weighted for stability for hands-free fun.
You can use it during showers and baths since it is submersible.
What makes it stand out? It is one of the best fake butt sex toys that comes with two openings and does not require extra accessories to operate, and you can dress it up to your liking. Male users find its ability to wear panties a turn on.
Which disadvantages must you keep in mind? The ribbed texture could be improved for greater stimulation. There is an initial latex smell that disappears after a while.
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 9547 people in the past 30 days
9.8
Customer Feedback
Based on cross-platform reviews
9.6
Brand Reputation
Based on web analytics & content of negative reviews
More features: hyper-realistic torso; breasts with silicone implants
Tantaly is an online sex toy shop with a wide range of products and several positive reviews. One of their Premium offerings is Tantaly Britney, which stands out for including a hyper-realistic torso, including soft F-cup breasts with silicone implants. The breasts even sag when the doll stands to simulate real breasts.
The lower torso features 18-inch waist, 5-inch deep butt supported by 3D legs, 5-inch vaginal tunnel length, and hips with circumference of 32.2 inches. We recommend it as the best realistic ass sex toy for doggy style. It includes fine details like goose bumps and pores.
Along with medical grade TPE, this doll incorporates a metal skeleton to maintain stable posture without deformation. However, you are still advised to store it with the breasts facing upwards as an extra precaution.
The 29.7-pound model offers dark and light color options. The combination of ass, vagina, and breasts offer users multiple avenues for mind-blowing orgasms.
Britney wears size S panties and 32B bras, which are easily available, and she comes in a discrete package that avoids prying eyes.
What makes it stand out? What’s there not to like? With this toy, you don’t have to choose between breasts and ass, or between ass and vagina. You can have it all in one package. The only thing that could limit your erotic experiences is your imagination.
Which disadvantages must you keep in mind? It is pricy, and the interior can be tedious to clean. A couple of buyers find the breast size decent but smaller than expected.
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 4584 people in the past 30 days
9.5
Customer Feedback
Based on cross-platform reviews
9.4
Brand Reputation
Based on web analytics & content of negative reviews
Tantaly Cecilia is available in fair and wheat color options. She weighs 19 pounds and has a tiny waist and hips circumference of 33.8 inches, which gives her a lifelike look and feel. The sex toy includes details such as subtle abs, a belly button, and two dimples on the butt to increase authenticity.
Such sex toys are handy with your partner around or away and convenient for users who have outgrown masturbation. Other owners use them to build their sexual stamina without the stigmatization of climaxing too early.
The realistic ass sex toy is available with butt and vagina. The vagina is layered with 6 large beads capable of elastic compression to massage the penis as the lines covering them squeeze it for double stimulation. The ass, which is 5-inch deep has similar but smaller beads. The butt and vagina also feature a sealed design that promotes suction.
To clean it, turn it upside down and flush the holes with plenty of water, dry it with a soft towel and let it air dry for a couple of minutes. The manufacturer provides buyers with one drying stick to start them off.
This is rated the best realistic ass sex toy. It is made from soft hypoallergenic medical grade TPE to prevent skin irritation. Use water-based lubricants for best results and spot it prior to application in case you have sensitive skin.
What stands out? Users are particularly impressed by how easy it is to switch between the ass and the vagina for different sensations. The toy’s weight enables it to stay steady during a hard pounding or hands-free doggy style.
What cons did we manage to find? The size makes it a hassle to maintain it.
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 8527 people in the past 30 days
9.4
Customer Feedback
Based on cross-platform reviews
9.2
Brand Reputation
Based on web analytics & content of negative reviews
More features: ultra-realistic butt and vagina tunnel texture; sealed tunnel design for more suction
Tantaly Louise features ultra-realistic butt and vagina openings that make it the best realistic ass sex toy for foreplay, anal and double penetration sex.
Notably, it is one of the few models that have parted legs for easy penetration in almost any position. They also form a stable base when thrusting.
It is made of soft medical grade TPE, which is responsible for the realistic pores and skin lines. The material is elastic, water-resistant, and hypoallergenic.
The tunnel, which is designed to adapt to the size of your penis is ribbed, textured and sealed for more suction. Owners recommend warming the canal and adding lubricant to enhance arousal.
Louise’s hips measurement is 36.6 inches and her waist is 8.3 inches. Although she is supposed to wear sexy lingerie of medium size, you may have to get a smaller size for the right fit. Avoid dark or fading clothes that may stain it.
It weighs 24.3 pounds and is about 6 ft. tall. The human proportions make this model feel authentic, and the booty moves side to side when you spank it.
What are its best features? It is lifelike in size and design with parted legs that make it user-friendly and a sealed tunnel that improves suction.
What could be improved? While most people appreciate the weight for stability, a few buyers find the fake butt sex toy too heavy to maneuver effortlessly. There are also users who would prefer a softer texture.
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 6256 people in the past 30 days
9.1
Customer Feedback
Based on cross-platform reviews
8.9
Brand Reputation
Based on web analytics & content of negative reviews
More features: weighty and stable enough for hands-free use
THRUST Pro Elite Tiana Ribbed Vagina and Ass Masturbator is a dual canal model with vagina and ass openings for more masturbation options. It is made of TPE devoid of phthalate. The manufacturer recommends using water-based lube for smooth entry.
The vagina is 7.5 inches in length with diameter of 0.5 inches while the anal opening is 5.5-inch long, and its diameter is snug at 0.3 inches.
It is available with hips of 36 to 38 inches and waist measurement of 27 to 30 inches, which fit medium-sized panties and US dress size 6 to 8 so you can doll it up.
THRUST Pro Elite Tiana Ribbed Vagina and Ass Masturbator is dark in color, sized to scale, and has sufficient weight to improve stability for hands-free use. The color adds an exotic element to the sex toy and users like it when it jiggles.
You can use it during showers and baths since it is submersible.
What do we love it for? It is one of the best fake butt sex toys that comes with two openings and does not require extra accessories to operate, and you can dress it up to your liking. Male users find its ability to wear panties a turn on.
What were we disappointed with? The ribbed texture could be improved for greater stimulation. Since hair adheres to it, it can be difficult to clean. There is an initial latex smell that disappears after a while.
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 3556 people in the past 30 days
8.9
Customer Feedback
Based on cross-platform reviews
8.4
Brand Reputation
Based on web analytics & content of negative reviews
More features: the sleeve is removable; discreet pearlescent case
Fleshlight Riley Reid Butt is wittily named after its flashlight form and designed after a popular stripper and adult movie star with a perky ass. It features Euphoria texture and is also available in Utopia texture for pocket pussy version.
The model has an upgraded coil design with stimulating pockets. The sleeve is removable for convenient cleaning, and its textured walls add to the sensation. It is made of Real Feel Super Skin, which is a thermoplastic elastomer, and extends up to 9 inches.
Our Budget Pick only comes with one orifice, but its functionality and affordable price range makes it the best fake butt sex toy for beginners.
There are three pockets separated by raised rings that generate pulsing sensations on the whole shaft to quickly bring you to orgasm. The pockets have varied tightness and become smaller as you penetrate to grip your penis. This allows you to control the level of intensity.
Although this toy is flexible, you will need lube. You can purchase FleshLube from the same Company.
Clean with lukewarm water after every use and check the rings for any residue that could cause buildup of mold and bacteria. Avoid soap, detergents, and lubricants with silicone or mineral oil.
Why did it make our list? It is affordable and comes in a discrete format and package, has multiple stimulating features, and it is also available in a version with a vagina.
What is not ideal about it? It only has butt opening and the nooks and crannies require more effort to clean.
To get the best fake butt sex toy, there are essential features you should keep in mind. We have reviewed them in detail and explained the role they play in your overall experience. We also discuss how to maintain such a toy in the included FAQ segment to keep it in peak performance.
Features to consider when choosing a realistic butt masturbator
A realistic ass sex toy is safe, easy to clean, and flexible to provide different types of masturbation. We discuss these qualities below.
Design
The most versatile fake butt sex toys come with diverse functions and customizable settings that add value to your purchase. As well as ass and vagina, some models can also be used as a vibrator.
Design also refers to the torso and available parts. With numerous models in the market, you can now choose the details you like in your fake butt sex toy. The common toys typically have a waist, hips, butt, and the openings. Advanced models may include breasts, or they may even feature a full torso, which makes it more lifelike.
Some brands are also available in different colors, so you can choose your favorite complexion. Ultimately, your sexual desires will dictate the right kind of toy for you.
Openings
Fleshlight Riley Reid Butt is a starter toy designed to be compact and discrete, so it only has one opening for the butt. However, all the other fake butt sex toys we have reviewed have anal and vaginal openings.
Some individuals only like anal sex; some enjoy the feeling of a vagina, and others love the thrill of double penetration. Although more openings are preferable because they provide more options to try out different sexual styles, the right model is the one that appeals most to your erotic fantasies.
Materials used
Silicone and rubber are the most common materials used to make ass sex toys because they have great flexibility that allows them to fit penises of different sized, and they are sturdy to hold up to any rough sex. They are also submersible and easy to clean.
Plastic is found in cost-effective models, but manufacturers are moving away from PVC due to phthalates and from latex, which may trigger skin allergies.
Most of the featured products utilize medical grade TPE, a versatile thermoplastic compound which ranges in texture from ultra-soft to semi-rigid. The TPE texture for ass toys is soft with a smooth texture and realistic feel. The FDA-compliant material is free of latex and phthalates.
To be on the safe side, always use water-based lubricants to minimize reactions that may deform the toy or trigger allergies in hypersensitive individuals.
Depth of the openings and their tightness
You certainly wouldn’t want an opening that can only accommodate the penis tip or one where you cannot feel the walls squeezing gently around your manhood, or worse, an extremely tight opening that almost cuts off your blood circulation.
The depth and tightness of the canals is expressed in inches. The average length and girth of an erect penis is 5.16 inches and 4.59 inches respectively. Realistic ass sex toys will always indicate the depth and diameter of the available openings in the product description. For instance, THRUST Pro Elite Tiana Ribbed Vagina and Ass Masturbator features a 0.5-inch wide vagina that is 7.5 inches in length and a 5.5-inch long anus with diameter of 0.3 inches. Knowing these statistics beforehand will help you to choose a toy that will provide a snug fit.
Some butt toys incorporate sleeves and layered walls that contract with penetration to intensify the sensation.
Structured tunnel
As mentioned above, different models use different methods of structuring the tunnel to increase stimulation. They include coils, pockets with varied grip, removable sleeves, raised rings that produce pulses, and ribbed textured walls. Tantaly Louise tunnel is sealed to improve suction.
Dimensions and weight
Dimensions matter when it comes to sex toys and their application and storage. You want a size that is large enough to make a realistic ass sex toy yet small enough to be stored discreetly after use. If you plan to travel with it, a compact model would be ideal.
The next major factor that influences the maneuverability of sex toys is weight. You should be able to shift sexual positions with ease, and a lightweight model would be preferable for cowgirl styles. It would also be easier to clean since you will likely have to flip it and flush it with water.
Lukewarm water and disinfectant suffices in most cases for models made of silicone, plastic and rubber. However, it is recommended to use approved products to prevent damage. Toys like Dirty Talk Interactive Realistic Vagina and Ass Masturbator include an antibacterial toy cleaner and a renewer powder that is applied once the toy is dry to soak up any residue. Avoid talcum powder, detergents, and soaps with fragrance, and check the waterproof rating before submerging the toy.
The best lube is water-based, which is compatible with most fake butt sex toys. It’s especially preferred for silicone products to avoid deformation and for latex to limit negative skin reactions.
The best realistic ass sex toys have varied diameter and depth with flexible canals that are designed to accommodate penises of different sizes. We have featured models with butt depth ranging from 4.5 inches to the 9 inches of the compact Fleshlight Riley Reid Butt.
Our Verdict
Dirty Talk Interactive Realistic Vagina and Ass Masturbator is a 3-in-1 rechargeable model that provides versatile erotic moments with a vibrator, anal and vaginal canals, and pleasurable moans activated by thrusting. It is our top pick for the best realistic ass sex toy, and it comes with a charging cable and cleaners to get you started.
The second and third positions are dominated by Tantaly brand, which is a testament of its quality and performance. Tantaly Britney boasts of a realistic profile with breasts, 3D legs, and simulated pores and goose bumps. It stays steady during use, fits easily available lingerie to turn up the heat, and you can get it in your preferred shade. It is built to last with sturdy medical grade materials.
Tantaly Cecilia does not have breasts, but she has stimulating beaded openings with sealed suctioning that will deliver that explosive orgasm. She also has cute butt dimples and a belly button that make this model one of the best fake butt sex toys.
