Hi - I'm Edgar! I'm a journalist and a product tester for JoyNights. I get paid to play with sex toys and tell you what they're like - it's the best job ever 😊
Please read more
Hi - I'm Justin! I've spent decades working on adult film sets, and also over a decade consulting for sex toy manufacturers. I love testing and reviewing cutting edge sexual read more
Last updated: June 11, 2024
JoyNights is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here
We’ve spent 100s of hours researching and testing Fleshlight products, and firmly believe the best Fleshlight for small penis sizes is Elsa Jean Tasty. The texture variety, tight orifice, and realistic orifice stand out.
We reviewed 43 different Fleshlights and chose the top 6 Fleshlight models on the market. We focused on the tightest and most textured models since these provide the best experience. Several are modeled after popular porn stars (such as Elsa Jean Fleshlight). These provide a realistic look and feel. We also review non-anatomical ones that are offer a great experience without looking like a Fleshlight.
For those with a predilection for adult entertainment star replicas, the Fleshlight Girls Elsa Jean offers an experience tailored to mimic the intimate anatomy of the notable actress, Elsa Jean. Our product testing team highlighted the patented SuperSkin material used in this model, emphasizing its exceptional likeness to the human skin. This feature, combined with the product’s lifelike mold, seeks to recreate a realistic and immersive experience, closely paralleling an actual intimate encounter.
Design Specifications and Sensation
This particular Fleshlight measures at a length of 9 inches, promising to comfortably house varying penis sizes. The internal sleeve is intricately designed with a series of bumps and ridges, purposed to heighten pleasure through increased stimulation. The entrance’s anatomically accurate appearance reinforces a genuine experience, catering to those who value authenticity in their sexual health devices.
Functional Features and User Comfort
Ensuring user comfort, the Fleshlight’s canal has been designed to be temperature responsive. Our team found this aspect particularly intriguing, noting its capacity to warm in tandem with the user and sustain a comfortable temperature throughout use. To optimize realism, we recommend pre-warming the device under warm water prior to engagement. Additionally, this model is equipped with a versatile end-cap, allowing users to modify suction intensity by adjusting airflow – a feature our testing team found to enhance the overall user experience.
Our Experience and Verdict
Upon thorough examination and testing, the standout features of the Elsa Jean Fleshlight were its authentic design and user adaptability. The removable sleeve facilitates hassle-free cleaning, which, when combined with the protective caps, ensures product hygiene and longevity. Our team particularly appreciated the attention to detail in the design, both aesthetically and functionally. In sum, for those seeking an intimate device that harmoniously blends realism with tactile pleasure, the Elsa Jean Fleshlight emerges as a top recommendation.
The Fleshlight Pink Lady Mini Lotus is similar to the original Lotus, with a few very important upgrades. This model still uses the Real-Feel Superskin, which gives you a realistic experience. The difference is the realistic opening, which looks (and importantly!) feels like the real deal.
Once you’ve entered the Fleshlight, the canal opens up a bit, giving you room to move in there. The inner sleeve has ridges that help to stimulate you during your session, increasing your pleasure. These ridges are more subtle than other models, but it gives you a realistic sexual experience that makes it well worth trying out.
This model has an adjustable end-cap that allows you to control the amount of suction you get when using it. All you need to do is tighten or loosen this piece to create the sensation you prefer. This can even be done as you’re using it for added convenience.
The outer case is black, with texturing on the sides to keep it from slipping around in your hand as you use it. We found the case to be very durable. It has a cover for the opening as well, to keep this area clean and make the device more discreet.
Why did it make our list?
Adjustable suction
Great as a first toy
Textured interior
Tight entry
Easy to clean
What is not ideal about it?
Internal ridges are more subtle than other models
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 3556 people in the past 30 days
9.7
Customer Feedback
Based on cross-platform reviews
9.2
Brand Reputation
Based on web analytics & content of negative reviews
More features: textured walls, laced with ridges and nubs; removable soft sleeve
There are a lot of toys on the market but not all of them are created with the attention to detail that the Fleshlight Girls Butt Riley Reid has to offer. It is a high-quality device that is designed to replicate Riley Reid’s perfect bottom, so you can try out all of your Riley fantasies in the comfort of your bedroom.
This model has a coiled design with ribbing and pleasure pockets on the inside to help stimulate you as you use it. This also increases the realism since it feels almost identical to a real woman’s derriere.
Another great feature this Fleshlight has to offer is the strong suction, which you can adjust to tighten or loosen it as needed to fit your member perfectly. This adjustment is done using the end-cap, giving you the perfect suction for the most intense pleasure possible.
Though it is cold to start with, this model is temperature responsive. You can run it under warm water before you get started, plus it will maintain this warm temperature as you use it, responding to the temperature of your body parts.
The Fleshlight Girls Butt Riley Reid includes a Pearlescent case for a discreet place to store your new toy and a sample of the Fleshlube. The soft sleeve is removable for easy cleanup at the end of each session.
As its name suggests, the Fleshlight Girls Janice Griffith is molded right from Janiсe herself, giving you the realistic feel of having this beauty in bed with you to give your fantasies new life. The sleeve is a SuperSkin “Eden” insert, which is textured with rings, ridges, and bumps that stimulate you and create a tantalizing experience every time.
The case is pearlescent, with an easy-grip texture to keep it firmly in your hand, or your partner’s, during your sessions, no matter how long or short they are. This case also includes an adjustable end-cap, which can increase or decrease the airflow to create the perfect suction for your personal tastes. There is also a cover for the opening, creating the look of a plastic flashlight for discreet storage or travel.
Another great feature is the coloring of the vaginal-like opening and the inner sleeve. Unlike other models that have a pinkish hue, this one is medium-toned, just like Janice Griffith herself. This helps to increase the fantasy since it doesn’t just feel like her, it looks like her as well.
The sleeve is removable to make cleanup a breeze, especially when you have to wash out all those nooks and crannies inside. This also makes it easier to warm up the sleeve before you use it for an even more realistic feel.
This Fleshlight comes with a small sample package of lubricant. Larger bottles and a handy Fleshlight sleeve warmer can also be purchased separately.
More features: open-ended; waterproof; removable sleeve
If you’re looking for a new Fleshlight but prefer a discreet model instead of one that looks like a woman’s private parts, the Fleshlight Go Torque may be the one for you. This piece has a transparent design on both the case and the sleeve, so it doesn’t look like you have a vagina in your drawer, plus it gives you the option of watching the action as you use it.
As well as the discreet design, this model is lightweight and compact, making it more portable and storable. This size is also better for men with less girth since it fits them perfectly.
This model has a cyclonic opening that coils into the sleeve, where there is a mix of soft fingers and ribbed twists to stimulate you as you move inside of it. It is also temperature responsive, so it warms up as you use it to give the feel of a real woman for the most satisfying experience possible.
The design of this piece is open-ended, though there is an end-cap you can add to create more suction if needed. This end-cap can also be used when storing the Fleshlight to keep the inside as clean and hygienic as possible.
The inner sleeve is removable for simple cleaning, though it does take a long time to dry afterward. You can speed up the process by patting it with towels to get rid of the excess water.
What are its best features?
Transparent
Adjustable end-cap
Screw top
Removable sleeve
What could be improved?
Long drying time after cleaning
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 5900 people in the past 30 days
9.3
Customer Feedback
Based on cross-platform reviews
9.0
Brand Reputation
Based on web analytics & content of negative reviews
A particular strength of the Fleshlight QUICKSHOT Vantage is its suitability for individuals of smaller to average sizes. While it might provide a tighter fit for users with a more substantial girth, our product testing team noted its compact size offers high portability and easy storage. Its dimensions make it an ideal fit for inconspicuous placement in a drawer or closet.
The external plastic component of the QUICKSHOT Vantage is designed to flex and bend with use, enhancing comfort during application. However, this flexible quality does contribute to additional noise production, which our testers suggested might not be ideal for situations where discretion is required. The clear plastic design also offers an intriguing visual element, allowing users to witness every moment of their session.
Innovative Features and Versatility
Internally, the open-ended sleeve incorporates non-anatomical nodules and chambers designed to enhance stimulation, contributing to a more satisfying experience. This open-ended structure provides multiple usage options, allowing the user to move it along the full length of the penis or for added stimulation during partner engagement, such as during oral sex. The design facilitates usage from either end, presenting no ‘correct’ method for its utilization.
The QUICKSHOT Vantage also includes twist-to-lock caps for both ends of the unit, offering variability in the experience. The caps can be attached for shallow stimulation or removed to enable a longer stroke. Furthermore, these caps serve a practical role in maintaining the cleanliness of the device between uses.
Maintenance and Cleaning
Historically, Fleshlights have been associated with complex cleaning processes. However, our product testers found the QUICKSHOT Vantage to be the most straightforward male masturbator to clean that they have encountered. This feature alone provides significant appeal, especially for those who might be unfamiliar with Fleshlight maintenance.
Our Experience and Verdict
The Fleshlight QUICKSHOT Vantage delivers a compact, versatile, and satisfying user experience, making it particularly appealing for individuals of smaller to average sizes. Its flexible and visual design, combined with the adjustable end caps and open-ended sleeve, provide a variety of stimulation options and engagement levels. While the noise level might be a drawback in certain contexts, it is significantly outweighed by the product’s ease of cleaning, a notable improvement in the Fleshlight range. Our product testing team highly recommends the QUICKSHOT Vantage, particularly for those new to Fleshlight products or who desire a straightforward maintenance experience.
Are you interested in buying a Fleshlight? You’re definitely not alone; in fact, around 42% of men own or have bought a sex toy. And Fleshlight is by far the most popular toy at the moment.
There are a lot of different Fleshlights on the market, though not every model will fit every man perfectly. Those who are smaller in the pants need a tighter model to give them the proper stimulation and the best finishing results. If you’re interested in the best Fleshlight for a small penis, check out the following sections to help you decide which one is the right one for you.
Features to consider when choosing a Flashlight masturbator
If you’re interested in the best Fleshlight for a small penis, there are a few features you should consider. This will ensure that you’re getting the right one to fit your member and give you the sensation you’re looking for.
Real-look or non-anatomical?
There are two types of Fleshlights to choose from. These are real-look and non-anatomical models. The real-look ones actually look like the body part they are meant to simulate. For instance, the top of the Fleshlight Pink Lady Mini Lotus looks like a woman’s vagina, while the Fleshlight Girls Butt Riley Reid is almost identical to a woman’s backside. This gives your fantasies new life since it doesn’t just feel like those parts, it looks like them as well, so you feel like it’s a real woman in bed with you. For those using their Fleshlight solo, this makes it much more entertaining and realistic.
There are also non-anatomical models, like the Fleshlight Go Torque, which are transparent plastic. This alters the experience since it doesn’t look like a woman’s parts but you still get the same type of stimulation and a great experience. These models also allow you to see your penis through the plastic, so you can watch yourself. This is also a bonus for couples play since some partners, be they women or men, can get turned on watching what they are helping you accomplish with your new toy. This stimulates them as well as you, even though they aren’t the ones experiencing the pleasure physically.
If it’s tight and textured inside
A tight Fleshlight is more important for those who are less-than-average in size since a wider model won’t give you the stimulation you’re looking for. A tighter model won’t have such issues since they are designed to grip your penis, no matter what size you are. This means even the smallest men will still enjoy the use of one of these toys.
The texturing of the inner sleeve can vary, depending on which model you choose. This also alters the intensity, with some models offering more stimulation for a faster finish while others slow things down for a long, yet enjoyable, session.
For instance, the Fleshlight Girls Janice Griffith has a mix of ridges, bumps, and rings. This variety of textures will offer a great deal of stimulation, so you’ll need to work to extend your endurance. It also helps you finish faster if you don’t have a lot of time but need some relief.
The Fleshlight Pink Lady Mini Lotus has some ridges as well, though it isn’t nearly as textured as some of the other models. This will still offer some pleasure but it won’t rush you into finishing. Instead, you can take your time with it the way you would if you had a real woman in bed with you, allowing you to increase your stamina and extend your performance.
There is no proper tightness or texture for any man, so be sure to consider what you’re looking for in a new toy before you buy one.
Length
The length of the models in our reviews isn’t as important as you may think. Most of them are 9 inches long, so even the longest of men can fit in them without reaching the end while still getting a great experience. Even if you do reach the end shorter models, like the Fleshlight Go Torque, they have removable end-caps, so you can remove it to fully fit if necessary, and makes for an easier cleanup.
The best part of these units is that they have texturing right to the end of the sleeve, so you can thrust into it as far as you like without sacrificing any pleasure.
Though most of the models in our reviews fit the full length of your penis, the Fleshlight QUICKSHOT Vantage is the exception. This piece is only 3.5 inches long but this is for a reason. This piece is designed to simulate oral sex, so you can move it over your member as you like or have it add some extra pleasure while your partner takes matters into their own hands or mouth. So, you aren`t losing anything by using a shorter model.
If it’s molded from your favorite porn star’s intimate areas
Though this may not matter to every man who`s looking for a new Fleshlight, some prefer a model that is fashioned after an actual woman. This includes models like the Fleshlight Girls Elsa Jean, which was molded from this lovely lady`s actual private parts. This gives you the feeling that you`re having intercourse with this particular woman, which can enhance your fantasies for an even better experience.
These models don`t just include vaginas, either. The Fleshlight Girls Butt Riley Reid is a replica of this port stars derriere, so you can try out some anal intercourse sessions with it while fantasizing that Riley is in your bed with you.
These models don’t just feel like these women, they are also colored with their natural skin tones, to make them look as real as they feel.
Color
The color of the Fleshlight that you choose likely won`t be the deciding factor on which one you buy. You probably won`t spend a lot of time looking at it, so it might not seem important. Of course, you do want the experience to feel as real as possible, so the coloring can help enhance this by giving the appearance of a real woman`s parts.
For instance, the Fleshlight Pink Lady Mini Lotus is quite pink, which isn`t very realistic since most women don`t have bright pink skin tones, even in their private areas. The models that are fashioned after the porn stars that you may have watched in action are colored to match that particular girl`s skin tone, making it look as real as it feels.
The Fleshlight Girls Janice Griffith is the perfect example of this. It has the same medium skin tone that Janice herself has, so it looks almost identical to what her actual private parts would look like. This enhances your fantasies for a more pleasurable experience.
Materials used
The materials used for your new toy need to be durable, especially if you`re going to be using your new Fleshlight regularly. The quicker it breaks down, the more often you`re going to need to replace it, which could end up costing a lot of money, especially when you consider how much some of these models cost. One of the most important things is using a proper water based lube, and avoiding oil based lube.
All of the real-feel models in our reviews are made of the SuperSkin material, which is soft plastic. This material is pliable but firm, plus it is sturdy enough to handle daily use. Of course, you need to take care of it, using the proper cleaning products to ensure that it doesn`t deteriorate.
The non-anatomical models also use soft plastic, though it is transparent instead of colored to match any skin tones. This material is still durable and strong, yet soft and pleasurable to use on your most sensitive area.
The cases on all of these models are hard plastic, with some texturing on the outside to make them easier to grip. When you add the cap over the entry end of the piece, it looks like a regular flashlight, which makes it a bit more discreet if someone should find it in your bedroom.
Cases and caps for storage and transportation
As we stated above, the cases for these models are made of durable plastic material that can handle regular use, even if you`re using it for multiple sessions every day. These cases aren`t just great for a sturdy piece to hold onto while you`re enjoying the use of your new toy, though. They are also a handy storage case for the inner sleeve when you aren`t using it, protecting this piece from damage, dirt, and germs.
The end-caps can be removed for easy cleaning but these also add to the sturdy case, keeping dirt and grime out of the unit during storage or travel. All of the models also include an extra cap to cover the opening. This area also needs to be protected to keep it looking good and free of dust and other irritants.
As well as offering protection, the case and caps also make it easy to store this piece. They give it the look of a flashlight, so it is a bit more discreet than leaving simulated lady parts in your drawer. They are also compact, so you can store this piece anywhere you like, including in a closet or under a bed.
The case is durable enough to withstand the rigors of travel. If you go on business trips or vacations alone or with a partner, having this little toy in your bag can enhance your away games. You still likely won`t want any customs agents pulling it out of your carry on but tossing it in your checked bags won`t be too much of an issue.
Removable sleeve
All of the models in our reviews include a removable sleeve. This is handy for a few reasons. When you`re ready to use your new toy, you can remove the sleeve and run it under some warm water before you get started. A woman`s vagina is warm when you enter it, so it only makes sense for your Fleshlight to feel the same for a more realistic experience. When it`s ready to go, it`s easy to reinsert it back into its case.
It`s also a good idea to clean out your Fleshlight after every use, especially if you`re finishing inside it. You don`t want any of your sperm drying inside of it or this could ruin your next session since it could alter the texture of the sleeve.
The best Fleshlight sleeve for a small penis is much easier to clean if you can remove it from the case. You can pull it out and rinse it out or use a cleaner designed for these products and a small brush if needed to get into all of those nooks and crannies. The sleeve is also soft, so you can bend it as needed to give it a proper cleaning, getting every bit of residue out for a clean, hygienic piece when you`re ready to use it again.
Fleshlight suction control
With the exception of the Fleshlight QUICKSHOT Vantage, all of the models in our reviews include an adjustable end-cap. This piece isn`t added for its aesthetic appeal, either. It can be tightened to create more friction or loosened for increased airflow to give you the right amount of suction to enhance your experience. The best part of this piece is that you can adjust it as you’re using the Fleshlight. If you find that you need more suction, you can twist it to reduce the airflow through the sleeve. If you find the suction to be too much, twist it the other way to increase the airflow as needed.
How to clean your Fleshlight masturbator
You need to keep your Fleshlight clean to prevent any bacteria or germ growth. Otherwise, you could end up with a urinary tract infection. To avoid such issues, be sure to clean your Fleshlight after every use using the following tips.
Remove the sleeve from the case.
Using cold water, rinse the inside out, removing any residue inside.
Use a proper Fleshlight cleaner if needed for a deeper clean.
Do not use soap and water as this could damage the sleeve material.
When the sleeve is clean, pat it dry with a towel, removing as much excess moisture as you can.
Let the sleeve dry completely overnight.
When it is completely dry, apply a layer of cornstarch or Renewing Powder to prevent stickiness.
After 5 uses, use some isopropyl alcohol after the initial cleaning to prevent any spreading bacteria.
Yes, many of the models on the market allow you to buy replacement sleeves. This way, if the original one that came in the case wears out or tears, you can purchase a new one without having to buy the entire piece. This can save you a bit of money, which is handy since some of the models available are rather pricey. Plus, it keeps you from throwing away perfectly good Fleshlight cases just because the inner sleeve has worn out.
No, the sleeves of the Fleshlight should not lose their tightness over time. Of course, you need to use it properly and use the correct cleaning products to ensure that it isn’t damaged at any time. The high-quality materials are meant to handle regular use, so as long as you follow the instructions, it should last for years.
The correct way to warm up your Fleshlight is to first remove the sleeve from the case. Then, place it under warm running water, allowing the water to run through the inside of the sleeve for about 5 minutes. Shake the sleeve gently to remove excess water and reinsert it into the case. Once these steps are complete, you can adjust the end-cap for your preferred suction, add your lubricant, and it’s ready to go.
Our Verdict
With so many different Fleshlight models on the market, it can be hard to choose the perfect one. Though all five of the models in our reviews are quality pieces, we have a few favorites.
Our top choice is the Fleshlight Girls Elsa Jean, which is modeled from this pretty lady’s vagina. It is 9 inches long, with a temperature-responsive SuperSkin sleeve inside the pearlescent case. The end-cap is adjustable for suction control and the sleeve is textured with bumps and ridges for added stimulation.
The Fleshlight Girls Butt Riley Reid is another piece modeled after a popular porn star, though this one is fashioned to resemble her derriere. This high-quality piece has a removable SuperSkin sleeve with a coiled design, ribbing, and pleasure pockets for a satisfying experience. It is temperature-responsive, with an adjustable end-cap and pearlescent case.
The Fleshlight Girls Janice Griffith looks as good as it feels, with the same medium skin tone as the real lady herself. It is modeled from her vagina, with a SuperSkin “Eden” insert with a variety of texturing inside. This 9-inch piece also has strong suction which can be adjusted using the end-cap and a removable sleeve for easy cleanup.
