Hi - I'm Martha! I'm a journalist and product tester at JoyNights. I love to share my ideas and personal sex life experience so that others can learn from my experiences.
read more
Hi - I'm Doris! I've spent decades working in the adult industry, including at several sex toy manufacturers as well as a large brick & mortar sex shop. I love reviewing read more
Last updated: April 11, 2025
JoyNights is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here
Do you want to silence sub by shoving dick up their mouth? Make no mistake, they’ll like it. And receive the healthy dose of humiliation. But don’t you dare to settle for a common dildo for the task, only opt for the best penis gags.
We’ve tryed on over 17 high-quality bondage silencers to find the perfect one in the Dildo Gag with Ball ''My two ways'' – a safe-to-use gag that sits on top of 6 noteworthy products. Amongst important features we’ve also considered variety of dildo lengths and secure fastening with lock options for every sub’s taste (literally). And now we are ready to share all the best options for your BDSM scenario to play in full glory.
"This penis gag has two dildos, bigger one being 6.2 inches long and 2 inches in diameter, both of them are fairly firm and won’t be pleasant for unexperienced users."
"This penis gag has realistic ridge dildo attachment with 2 inches of insertable length, this toy is comfortable to wear for a long time due to thought-through breathing holes."
More features: phthalates-free, 1.6 in ball diameter, can be used with padlock
First on our list is the Dildo Gag With Ball ”My two ways”, which is our Editor’s Choice. It is well constructed and not too intimidating, which makes it perfect for both beginners and those with experience. The dildo gag measures 2.4 inches in length with a 1.1-inch diameter. It won’t exactly be comfortable but you will be able to use it for a good amount of time. The dildo is made out of silicone with is nice as it won’t erode with use. As for the strap, it is made from faux leather which gives it a softer feeling to it. The buckle at the back means you can easily change the size, depending on who is wearing it.
The Dildo Gag With Ball ”My two ways” has this name because you can use it in two different ways. You can place the dildo part in your mouth for a gag, or you can flip it and place the ball end in your mouth to create a mouth dildo to use on your partner. The versatility is quite impressive, especially given its low price. The only issue with this penis gag is the rigidness of the dildo. It is very firm so when in your mouth, it is hard to move and thus can cause a gag reflex.
What makes it special?
Strap is easy to adjust
Size is manageable
Can be used in two ways
What cons did we find?
Penis part is rigid and can be uncomfortable in your mouth
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 6814 people in the past 30 days
9.7
Customer Feedback
Based on cross-platform reviews
9.2
Brand Reputation
Based on web analytics & content of negative reviews
On average, penis gags only cost about $30 so what do you get if you pay triple this price? The In and Out Penis Gag is our Premium Pick and is made for both comfort and desire. The 6-inch dildo length is not made for beginners but rather for those who want to improve their deep throating skills. The diameter, which is 2 inches wide, means you will have a very full feeling in your mouth. However, the PVC material of the dildo is more flexible than other options, which increases the overall comfort level.
The In and Out Penis Gag actually comes in two color choices, which is rare. You can choose from beige or black. The straps are made from faux leather and have a comfortable feel to them and the metal buckle and studs add a nice extra touch to the design. What’s unique about the In and Out Penis Gag is that the dildo is actually removable. This adds so much more versatility as you can simply remove the dildo when you want to use it on its own. You can also use the rounded edge of the dildo if you want your partner to pleasure you with the dildo.
Why did it make our list?
Comes in two color choices
Dildo is not too firm
Straps are comfortable
What is not ideal about it?
Very expensive
Not for beginners
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 6020 people in the past 30 days
9.6
Customer Feedback
Based on cross-platform reviews
9.1
Brand Reputation
Based on web analytics & content of negative reviews
Yes, the Double Mouth Dildo is intimidating at first glance. This is an extreme penis gag and not at all meant for beginners. However, there are plenty of people looking to increase their experience, and if that is you, then this penis gag will deliver. The construction is unique in that you have two options for using it. On one side you have a massive 6.2-inch dildo. On the other side, you have a 2-inch dildo. You can use either end in your mouth or on your partner. The versatility is pretty impressive.
The Double Mouth Dildo is made to look intimidating and will be perfect for any BDSM scenario. The large dildo is full of deep veins that will add a textured element. Then the straps are black faux leather with metal studs. The harness is thick and the metal buckle means you won’t be able to take it off unless another person helps you. Care was put into this toy as it is made from phthalate-free material and doesn’t have an off-putting odor, even when right out of the box. The one downside to the Double Mouth Dildo is that the gag is very stiff. Again, this is not at all meant for beginners.
Why are we impressed?
Perfect for expert users
Black and metal design is great for BDSM
Dual purpose gags
What negatives must you be aware of?
Penis gag is stiff
Length is very intimidating
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 8900 people in the past 30 days
9.4
Customer Feedback
Based on cross-platform reviews
9.3
Brand Reputation
Based on web analytics & content of negative reviews
As a whole, penis gags are not that expensive. Still, when it comes to sex toys, it’s always impressive when you can get a high-quality device at a reasonable price. The 9’s Orange Is The New Black is a good intermediary toy as it is not small enough for beginners but might not satisfy the most extreme users. And, thanks to its low price, you can easily afford this next step in your penis gag evolution. It measures 4 inches in length with a 1.5-inch diameter. The silicone material of the dildo can take a bit to get used to but is perfect if you want that full feeling in your mouth. As for the straps, they are made from faux leather and we really liked the orange stitching that adds a bit of character to the setup.
The 9’s Orange Is The New Black has a metal bucket that is adjustable and secure. Your partner won’t be able to easily take this toy off. However, the design of the penis gag has a rather large faux leather base to it. This is to provide stability but it gets in the way of other uses. Finally, there is no guarantee or refund policy. While the low cost of this toy means you won’t be losing out on money, a guarantee usually denotes higher quality toys.
Why are we impressed?
Very affordable
Orange stitching is unique
Great for the next step up from beginners
What negatives must you be aware of?
Penis base is a bit uncomfortable
no warranty or refunds available
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 7625 people in the past 30 days
9.3
Customer Feedback
Based on cross-platform reviews
9.2
Brand Reputation
Based on web analytics & content of negative reviews
For those that envision themselves wearing their penis gag for a lengthy time, comfort is of the essence. With the Realistic Dildo Ball Gag, you can wear it for hours thanks to the durable build and dimensions. The dildo only measures 2 inches long and has a diameter of 1 inch, making it the smallest option on our list. The dildo is made out of silicone which offers a nice, soft texture to your mouth and the faux leather strap won’t dig into your head. You can also easily adjust the straps and they won’t easily fall off thanks to the double buckle.
The Realistic Dildo Ball Gag is dual purpose. You can place the dildo into your mouth to act as a penis gag or you can flip it around and hold the ball end in your mouth and use the dildo on your partner. All the materials are hypo-allergenic, which is great if you have any sensitivities. It is also only 3.4 ounces in weight which further enhances the ability to wear this penis gag for long periods of time. One of the only downsides to the Realistic Dildo Ball Gag is its price. Even though it isn’t too expensive, it is on the pricier end of the spectrum.
What stands out?
Can be used in two ways
Straps are secure and comfortable
Small size is perfect for beginners
What cons did we manage to find?
A bit pricey
Only comes in one color
?
Consumer Engagement
Chosen by 5805 people in the past 30 days
9.1
Customer Feedback
Based on cross-platform reviews
8.7
Brand Reputation
Based on web analytics & content of negative reviews
More features: double buckle clasp, lock compatible
All the other penis gags on our list are in a domineering black color, so it’s refreshing to have a bit of a change. The Pink Mouth Penis Gag is more lighthearted than the other options and is definitely meant for beginners or those who want more comfort while playing. The dildo length is only 3.9 inches and the width is 1.3 inches, so it shouldn’t trigger a gag reflex. The bright pink straps are made from PU leather, which isn’t the most comfortable, but the buckle allows for easy adjustment.
The Pink Mouth Penis Gag also comes with a lock that you can attach to the buckle. This can take your playtime to the next level. The whimsical color means you can match your personality to your toy and offsets the often domineering black that most BDSM toys come in. There were some issues with the taste of the dildo. It is made from silicone which can have a rubbery taste to it. We suggest washing it a few times after your toy arrives and leaving it to air out before use. Furthermore, if you really want to assert control over your partner, this might not be the best toy. Even with the lock, the small size of the dildo means it is easy for the wearer to remove it on their own.
What makes it stand out?
Pink color is whimsical
Size is perfect for beginners
Includes a lock
Which disadvantages must you keep in mind?
Off-putting taste at first
Easy to take off on own
Things to Consider
When you’re ready to go to the next level in your bedroom, a penis gag can take you there. These devices require a lot of communication and trust with your partner, so be sure to communicate your needs. Then, take your time and go through your options to see what will satisfy your needs.
How to Wear Dildo Mouth Gag
At first, it can be hard to wear a dildo mouth gag. If you don’t have any experience, you might want to start with other similar toys. For example, this list of the best open-mouth gags can help you keep your mouth open and learn how to relax your muscles.
Penis gags can be used in several ways depending on design – as gags or as face-fucking toys.
Securely attach the straps around your head and test it out. You want the straps to be in place but if they are too tight it can hurt and if they are too loose it can be easy for the wearer to take it off on their own.
Practice in short intervals to get the hang of it and make any adjustments as needed.
Safety Tips
The biggest safety tip when wearing a dildo mouth gag is to start slow. Choose a smaller size and only wear it for a few minutes at a time. As you become more comfortable, you can try larger sizes or longer times.
If you can’t communicate to your partner by words that you need to stop, be sure to agree on a hand gesture. Even if you are in a BDSM relationship, you still have the power to stop when you want to.
How to Pick the Best Penis Gags
Picking your penis gag is not an easy choice. This is a toy that is not as popular as others and only those who are truly ready should purchase one. Be sure to go through the features and decide what will be the best fit for you and your partner.
There are also alternatives to penis gags if you still aren’t sure what you are looking for. For example, this list of the best ball gags has different options to consider.
Materials
There is some difference when it comes to materials used with a penis gag. The penis dildo itself is made with a rubber material, usually silicone. This material is non-porous so you don’t have to worry about the buildup of bacteria.
PVC is also a common material and has a more flexible texture. If you are worried about hitting your teeth or being uncomfortable, PVC can be the better option.
Dildo length
The length of your penis gag is perhaps one of the most important features to consider. Anyone new to gags should start out as small as possible and only move up to very large gags when they feel they are ready.
On our list, we have many different size options. The smallest is the Realistic Dildo Ball Gag which measures just 2 inches. However, the largest is the Double Mouth Dildo which measures 6.2 inches.
Dildo gags rarely feature dongs that are longer than 3 inches, that’s the proper length to not choke the user
Gag adjustment
To help with the gag adjustment, there is a series of straps that go around the user’s head. There will then be a buckle that you can secure in place. Take some time to figure out the best position and tightness as this will be a factor in how long it is worn.
Most gags are compatible with locks and some even come with them. A lock can be fun but the utmost of trust needs to be in place first.
Comfort of wear
For the most part, you want your penis gag to be comfortable to wear. This way, you can keep it on for longer. Look for a penis gag that has adjustable straps that will fit different head sizes. Faux leather is perhaps the softest material and won’t cut into your scalp.
Also remember that dildo should fit tightly in sub’s mouth but leave some space for tongue to move freely enough to allow swallowing the saliva. Bigger dick gags are options for those who want a harsh scenario to play out.
If you want more options when it comes to the best face strapons, you can check out this list.
Design
There are two main designs to consider when searching for different penis gag bondage items. One is a basic penis gag and the other is a two-headed gag.
The other option is a penis gag that has a smaller ball end on the other side. This way, you can place the ball gag in your mouth and then use the penis side on your partner. With this design, you have more options.
One final design is with a dildo that is removable. Only one product on our list, the In and Out Penis Gag, has this feature. It’s a nice quality because you can use the gag as-is, or you can remove the dildo and use it for many different uses.
You should only wear a penis gag as long as you are comfortable doing so. While it might be used in BDSM activities, your partner should still be aware of your hard limits and constantly check in that you are able to breathe and are not too uncomfortable. As always, start by using a penis gag for short periods of time to get used to it and always start with a small size first.
The larger the penis gag is, the bigger the chance it will hurt your teeth. Always start with a smaller size, both in length and width. Then, you can learn to relax your jaw and work your way to a larger gag.
Our Verdict
We hope you have been able to find a suitable penis gag for all your needs, whether you are a beginner or an expert. The Dildo Gag With Ball ”My two ways” is our Editor’s Choice. It is fairly comfortable to wear and can be used in multiple positions. If you are able to spend more money, you might want to consider the In and Out Penis Gag. With a 6-inch removable dildo, you can really get your money’s worth. Finally, if you are on a budget, the 9’s Orange Is The New Black is a worthwhile choice. It has unique orange stitching that adds a bit to the design. These are just a few options when you are looking at the best penis gags. Remember to pick one that is comfortable and that both you and your partner can enjoy.
References
1.
Frontiers | Embodiment and Humiliation Moderation of Neural Responses to Others' Suffering in Female Submissive BDSM Practitioners
Giving and receiving pain are common in the practice of BDSM (bondage-discipline, dominance-submission and sadism-masochism).
