7 Gorgeous Fisting Dildos for Daring People

From this article, you will learn everything about the best fisting dildos - how to use them safely, how to choose the one that fits you and how to clean after each use
By
reviewed
Reviewed by
Last updatedLast updated: December 23, 2021
Joy Nights is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here
Joy Nights is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here

Not for the faint of heart, fisting dildos are advanced sex toys that should be used cautiously and slowly. While they may not be right for beginners, those who want a full, stretched feeling may want to try one out.

Fisting is common enough and the best fisting dildo mimics the sensation of a human fist. They can be used by men and women and are shaped for easy insertion, followed by a very large girth. While fist-shaped dildos share similar characteristics, there are many options to choose from. Your ultimate choice will depend on the length, circumference, and style. In out fisting dildo guide, we’ll present you with seven of the best options for your consideration. We hope they bring you the experience you are craving.

Top 7 Fisting Dildo Reviews 2022

1.

Doc Johnson Belladonna's Bitch FistEditor’s Choice

Features
  • Insertable length: 8 in
  • Shape: fist
  • Circumference: 9.5 in
  • Material: PVC

More features: allergen free, submersible

Despite the rather graphic name, the Doc Johnson Belladonna’s Bitch Fist is one of the finest fisting dildos that we could find. It has an 8-inch insertable length and a 9.5-inch circumference. With a PVC build, it is allergen free and you can submerse it in water.

The Doc Johnson Belladonna’s Bitch Fist is extremely realistic. Despite it being made out of PVC, at first glance you might just mistake it for a human fist. There are subtle veins under the skin and even the nailbeds look real. The dildo has a soft texture to it so it isn’t as overwhelming as you may think. Still, it is hard enough for easy insertion, which is also helped by the thumb that sticks out just a bit to help you east it into yourself.

What are its best features?

  • We love the realism of the Doc Johnson Belladonna's Bitch Fist. There’s a good chance you might not know if your dildo or your partner is inside of you. The spongy texture allows you to become comfortable with it inside of you but there is still enough strength to the dildo that insertion is not difficult. If you are looking to increase your dildo collection, this might just be your new prized possession.

What could be improved?

  • Unfortunately, the Doc Johnson Belladonna's Bitch Fist does not have a suction cup base. While you can still use this fisting dildo on your own, the lack of a suction cup can hamper the overall experience.
RELATED: 8 Awesome Anal Dildos for the Most Sensuous Butt Play
2.

Gut PuncherUpgrade Pick

Features
  • Insertable length: 12.5 in
  • Shape: fist
  • Circumference: 10.25 in
  • Material: PVC

More features: smooth texture, 3 sizes

Aptly named, the Gut Puncher is certainly long enough to reach the furthest reaches of your insides, although we don’t really recommend you go that far with it. the Gut Puncher has an insertable length of 12.5 inches, which is plenty more than the average person needs, either anally or vaginally. Furthermore, the circumference is 10.25 inches in size, which means this fisting dildo is definitely not for beginners.

Those who have plenty of experience with fisting will, however, love the Gut Puncher. Its black color and smooth texture gives it a menacing look to it and is great for bondage. You can also choose a natural tan or brown color, if you are looking for more variations.

Why did it make our list?

  • We especially loved the menacing look to the Gut Puncher. While this dildo may not be for everyone, those wanting a more intense experience will surely love it. Furthermore, we love that there are actually three sizes to choose from, which is great if you are a but nervous about using such a large device. Don’t worry, though, as the sizes aren’t too small as they only come in XL, XXL, and 4XL.

What is not ideal about it?

  • The Gut Puncher is almost three times the price of the average anal fisting toy. And while most reviews state that the price is worth it, it is a major consideration for most people. You may want to try a more inexpensive fisting dildo first, just to ensure this is the experience you want to continue with.
3.

Master Series Knuckles Clenched Fist DildoBest for Hands-Free Use

Features
  • Insertable length: 8.5 in
  • Shape: fist
  • Width: 3.2 in
  • Material: PVC

More features: suction cup, phthalate free

There is a time and a place for each dildo and sometimes you just want to take matters into your own hands. The Master Series Knuckles Clenched Fist Dildo allows you to do just this, thanks to the suction cup base that is incredibly sturdy.

Thanks to the 8.5-inch insertable base and the 3.2-inch width, you will be pleasantly satisfied with the Master Series Knuckles Clenched Fist Dildo. It has a lot of nice touches, including the realistic creases in the hand and the life-like fingers. The top also is more pointy than other fisting dildos, which means insertion is that much easier. This is a good fisting dildo for people of all experience levels.

What makes it special?

  • Just looking at the suction cup base, you can tell that this is a solid construction. Sometimes the base on a dildo is a bit flimsy and you have to be delicate with your usage. However, with the Master Series Knuckles Clenched Fist Dildo you can really go to town and not worry about it unsticking from the surface you have attached it to. The tapered tip is also a really nice touch and even experienced fisters will appreciate the ease at which this can enter you.

What cons did we find?

  • There is an attempt at making the Master Series Knuckles Clenched Fist Dildo seem lifelike but we wish it had gone just a bit further. The hands are so close to lifelike and if they had just spent a bit more time with the mold, it would be there.
4.

Give A Hand - Fisting DildoBest Value

Features
  • Insertable length: 8.6 in
  • Shape: hand
  • Width: 2.95 in
  • Material: PVC

More features: flared base, color variations

When it comes to dildos of any design, prices can quickly skyrocket to hundreds of dollars. While it might be nice to be able to afford whatever toy you want, most people are operating under some form of a budget. The Give A Hand Fisting Dildo allows you to have a good product at a reasonable price, and you won’t be disappointed.

The Give A Hand Fisting Dildo features an insertable length of 8.6 inches and a width of 2.95 inches. It is neither the largest on our list nor the smallest, which makes it accessible for many different people. You can choose a flesh color, a black color, or a fun pink color, depending on your tastes.

Why did it make our list?

  • We liked the affordability of the Give A Hand Fisting Dildo. And even though it is a good price, you are still getting a quality product. The PVC material is flexible but still rigid enough for insertion. The three color choices are a nice touch and the design of the fist allows for many people to use it. Furthermore, the flared base is also a nice touch and you can use it easily with a partner or on your own.

What is not ideal about it?

  • While we are not expecting the most amazing design given the price, the overall look of the Give A Hand Fisting Dildo is a little, well, plasticky. It doesn’t offer any extras that would make it look like a real fist and the construction has a fake shine to it that can be a bit of a turn-off.
5.

Doc Johnson Belladonna's Magic HandBest for Experienced Users

Features
  • Insertable length: 11.5 in
  • Shape: hand
  • Width: 2.7 in
  • Material: PVC

More features: phthalate free

Generally speaking, fisting dildos are not meant for those with little experience. However, even if you have some experience, not every fisting dildo may be right for you. Those with plenty of fisting experience, however, are always on the lookout for their next challenge and the Doc Johnson Belladonna’s Magic Hand may finally be the toy you’ve been searching for.

With an insertable length of 11.5 inches and a width of 2.7 inches, this is a nice, sturdy design that will leaving you full in the best way possible. Another impressive aspect of the design is the lifelike texture. You can see the creases in the hand and the wrist, making it a fantasy come true.

What do we love it for?

  • Many fisting dildos have their hand mold in the shape of a fist and while this can feel great once inside of you, it can make insertion quite difficult. The Doc Johnson Belladonna's Magic Hand has a tapered tip to it, thanks to the design of three fingers. This allows you to insert the dildo much easier, especially if you are engaging in some solo play. The full feeling still exists further on, which makes this a dual-purposed toy.

What were we disappointed with?

  • The Doc Johnson Belladonna's Magic Hand can be a bit difficult to clean, thanks to the design. The crevices are rather deep around the fingers so you will want to really get in there in order that mold and bacteria don’t start to grow.
Features
  • Insertable length: 7.5 in
  • Shape: hand
  • Width: 2.9 in
  • Material: PVC

More features: flared base, phthalate-free

Despite the term of fisting dildos, there are some toys that are slightly smaller than you would imagine. This allows them to be used by people with different levels of experience. The Master Series Stuffer Fisting Hand Dildo comes in the shape of a hand but is more compact than other options on our list.

With an insertable length of 7.5 inches and a width of 2.9 inches, this fisting dildo is excellent for newbies. Furthermore, its shape really allows for an easier experience. Because they fingers are pointed together, insertion is easier. You can ease your way into the wider part of the palm and can stop at any time to become more comfortable.

What are our favorite features?

  • Overall, we liked that there is a beginner option to fisting dildos and the Master Series Stuffer Fisting Hand Dildo is certainly that. You don’t want to be left out simply because you are new to the experience. With this dildo, you can still experience what it is like to have a whole hand inside of you, simply at a slightly smaller scale. Furthermore, the suction cup base is a nice touch and really lends itself to solo play.

What could be better?

  • As much as we liked the smaller size, having multiple sizes to choose from would have made the Master Series Stuffer Fisting Hand Dildo more accessible. It can be hard to find such a tapered top and if you were looking for a fisting dildo that is easier to insert but still large in size, this would have been a great option.
7.

Fist It Up - Fisting DildoBest Design

Features
  • Insertable length: 8 in
  • Shape: fist
  • Width: 3.4 in
  • Material: PVC

More features: flared base, color variations

The Fist It Up pretty impressive but slightly smaller than other toys, and so may be a good place to start out on. With an insertable length of 8 inches and a width of 3.4 inches, it is not much larger than extra large traditional dildos.

If you are looking for a bold color choice, the Fist It Up is a good consideration. Not only does it come in black and flesh colors, but it also comes in pink, which can add a bit of excitement to the bedroom. It has a nice flared base to it, which means you can use it well and not worry about loosing your grip.

Why did it make our list?

  • We really liked the price of the Fist It Up. It is a bit cheaper than other fisting dildos and while its quality may not be up to par with other toys, it is still able to offer you a great experience. The other thing we liked is that the measurements are a bit more accessible than other fisting dildos. Sometimes it’s nice to acclimatize yourself to the feeling and with a smaller fist, you are able to do just that.

What is not ideal about it?

  • Despite its stated measurements, you may be a bit surprised when you get the Fist It Up, as it can actually be a bit larger in real life. While not a deal breaker, it is something to be aware of. Furthermore, we found the small beading on the dildo a bit off-putting. Texture is great, but this looks more like a cheap mold than anything meant for actual pleasure.

Things to Consider

When you’re ready to feel a more intense sensation, a fisting dildo may be just what you need. They can be used anally or vaginally and even beginners can start off with a smaller toy before working their way up to an imposing design.

Tips for Using Fisting Dildo

7 Gorgeous Fisting Dildos for Daring People

We recommend using a generous amount of lube to ensure a smooth entrance

Using a fisting dildo requires the use of lube. No matter how much experience you have, a fisting dildo is quite large and imposing.

  • Not only will lube make your experience more pleasurable but it will make it easier to insert your dildo.
  • Furthermore, you should go slowly with a fisting dildo. Sometimes insertion can take up to an hour. You don’t want to ram anything inside of you as this can cause severe internal damage.
  • If your body is just not feeling up to the task, it’s ok to substitute with a smaller toy.

How to Pick the Best Fisting Dildo

When choosing a fisting dildo, you should take into account your experience with the activity. Fisting needs a lot of practice to master, and you should work your way up to a larger, more imposing dildo. Always pay attention to the size and shape as these will determine how easy it is to use the toy.

Shape

Now, when we talk about fisting dildos, the shape should be pretty explicit. And while all of the dildos on our list are in the form of a hand, there is some slight variation.

For example, the Doc Johnson Belladonna’s Magic Hand and the Give A Hand Fisting Dildo have some fingers pointing upwards. This means insertion is easier as it has a tapered feeling to it.

In contrast, the Doc Johnson Belladonna’s Bitch Fist and the Gut Puncher are indeed more in a fist shape. These are better suited for experienced users as it can be hard to fit so much of a dildo inside all at once.

Material

All of the dildos on our list are made from PVC Trusted Source What is Polyvinylchloride (PVC) This definition explains the meaning of Polyvinylchloride and why it matters. www.kinkly.com . This is a good material for these types of dildos. Not only is it easy to clean and won’t break, but it is a slightly more bendable material.

This flexibility is needed to allow you to angle the dildo and make it easier to insert.

Circumference

Back to basic math, the circumference of an object is the measurement around the circle. Often this measurement is used for a dildo, but you may also find the width, which refers to the diameter or measurement across the circle.

The Doc Johnson Belladonna’s Magic Hand has the smallest circumference, of 2.7 inches. In contrast, the Gut Puncher has a circumference of 10.25 inches.

With these measurements, there is an important note to understand. Due to the design, different parts of a fisting dildo will have different measurements. So, there is usually an option to only insert part of the dildo inside of you. This has the added benefit of being able to slowly stretch yourself out to accommodate the larger part of a fisting dildo.

Insertable length

7 Gorgeous Fisting Dildos for Daring People

Beginner models can be about 5 inches long while experienced users can take in dildos starting at 12 inches

For fisting dildos, the insertable length refers to how much of the toy can safely enter you. This measurement won’t take into account the base or the handle. For our dildos, the smallest length is the Master Series Stuffer Fisting Hand Dildo, which measures 7.5 inches. On the other end of the spectrum is the Gut Puncher, as it measures 12.5 inches long.

Don’t get too overwhelmed by the insertable length. Even though people like to boast, most people are content with 6 to 7 inches in length and it’s ok if there is some dildo leftover. Indeed, the human rectum is only about 5 inches long Trusted Source Rectum Anatomy, Diagram and Function The rectum is the concluding part of the large intestine that terminates in the anus. The average length of the human rectum may range between 10 and 15 cm. www.healthline.com , although it can be stretched larger.

Design

Overall, the design of a fisting dildo will be pretty similar to others. However, you can find some slight variations.

Skin tone is perhaps the biggest design difference you can find. Both the Give A Hand Fisting Dildo and the Fist It Up dildo offer you the standard flesh and black colors, as well as a fun pink option.

FAQ

Ideally, you should use a water-based lube with your fisting dildo. Water-based lubes are non-allergenic and are much easier to clean up afterwards. They are also very thin, which is what you want when you already have a lot inside of you.

Cleaning your fisting dildo is relatively straight forward. You will want to use warm soapy water and make sure you rinse it thoroughly. Most of these toys will have creases in them, usually around the fingers, so be sure you get into all the cracks for a thorough clean.

Our Verdict

If fisting is your cup of tea, then you know how important a fisting dildo is. Whether you want to use one with your partner or on your own, that feeling of fullness will lead to intense pleasure. Our Editor’s Choice is the Doc Johnson Belladonna’s Bitch Fist. Incredibly lifelike and with solid dimensions, this is a great choice for those with a bit more experience. If you have the budget and want a fisting dildo that will never disappoint, then the Gut Puncher is a solid choice. While its 12.5-inch insertable length means it is not for beginners, experienced fisters will be in awe of its construction. Finally, those wanting the best fisting dildo while on a budget will appreciate the Give A Hand Fisting Dildo. It has a flared base and a tapered design to maximize pleasure and comfort. Fisting is an intense experience and with the right dildo, you can feel everything you’ve always dreamed of.

References

1.
What is Polyvinylchloride (PVC)
This definition explains the meaning of Polyvinylchloride and why it matters.
2.
Rectum Anatomy, Diagram and Function
The rectum is the concluding part of the large intestine that terminates in the anus. The average length of the human rectum may range between 10 and 15 cm.
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *